The Myth of Civil Military tensions
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS

Hasan, Yasir set Pakistan on victory path in first Test against New Zealand

Russia’s Taliban connection is good for USA: But why?

Allama Sibtain Sabzwari asks religious orators to preach peace in Majlis

SP Tahir Dawar murder case: Has PTM been exposed?

Pakistan women’s team facing financial crisis

Sharif family to face four new cases

Saudi sports diplomacy: An effort to bury Khashoggi’s killing

Israeli sources admit Hamas possesses game-changing missiles

Iran says ready to fight terror on Pakistani soil

Zulfi Bukhari case: “PM is not all powerful”

NDS, ISIS or TTP?: JIT to probe who killed SP Dawar

Brothers allegedly murder sister, cousin in suspected honour killing in Shangla

Aasia cannot leave Pakistan due to pending review: Qureshi

Bipartisan Senate bill to suspend US arms exports to Saudi Arabia

CIA concludes Saudi crown prince ordered Khashoggi assassination: Washington Post

Yemen: A blot on the global conscience

SP Dawar & Information War: Pakistan lost both?

Pakistan: Two killed, several injured after blast rocks Karachi

Are we invading Russia in winter? — politicians, media react to PM's alleged statement on U-turns

The deplorable situation of Pakistani workers in Saudi Arabia

ISO President condemns pro-Israel speech in Parliament of Pakistan

New Zealand dismissed for 153 after Williamson's 50 on opening day of 1st Test against Pakistan

India: The ‘troublemaker’ in South Asia

Why Is Bahraini Regime Mounting Crackdown on Opposition?

The Eleventh Imam, Hasan ibn ‘Ali (al-Askari) (as)

Afghanistan’s Rivers Could Be India’s Next Weapon Against Pakistan

Saudi hosts new conference in shadow of critic’s murder

Is Indo-Pak nuclear war imminent?

PTM: A practical manifestation of 5th generation warfare against Pakistan

US may extradite Gulen to ease Turkey pressure on Saudi Arabia: Report

Russia says US using white phosphorous bombs in Syria

Pakistani security forces recover 5 abducted Iranian guards

Body of SP Tahir Khan Dawar brought back to Pakistan: FO

Will NAB bow down to the opposition’s mounting pressure?

Misleading headlines: What has the CJP said?

Are Nawaz Sharif & Khaqan Abbasi traitors?

Kidnapped from Pakistan, murdered in Afghanistan: The curious case of SP Dawar

Baluchistan under fifth generation warfare

Should the Donald be kicked out of America?

US Senate considers legislation to punish Saudi Arabia

Why the US anti-Hezbollah battle for Israel is lost?

Pakistan making efforts to bring Aafia back: Qureshi

Sindh govt suspends registration of City School, Beacon House over failure to comply with SHC orders

Is government seriously clamping down upon extremists?

Model Town Tragedy: Will the SC summon Sharif brothers?

Water war between Pakistan and Afghanistan?

Slain JUI-S leader’s secretary ‘missing’: Is he dead?

Saudi monarchy beheaded 80 Pakistanis out of over 3000 prisoners since 2014

Recording links Saudi crown prince to Khashoggi assassination: Report

US to squeeze Iranians 'very hard': John Bolton

A review of Ahlulbayt TV’s documentary: “ Violent extremism in Pakistan: Roots, growth and support ”

France Announces Eiffel Scholarship for Pakistani Higher Education Students

Pakistan invites Iran for talks on shelved IP gasline project

What now for the TLP?

Yet another honor killing: This time by PML-N leader

Russia & Israel: Friends or Enemies?

‘Welcoming’ Canada ready to take in Aasia Bibi: PM Trudeau

Is TLP a political “Cryptocurrency”?

Suspense continues: Is Nawaz Sharif going to be jailed again?

Persian Gulf kingdoms normalizing ties with Israel Saudi decision: Hezbollah official

Tehran had 'credible information' about Saudi plot to assassinate top Iranian officials: Zarif

Exports to Iran from Pakistan not to be affected due to US sanctions: FO

Without including Houthis Yemen mediation not possible: MWM

Pashto dying slow death in Peshawar schools

Neither law nor order

Privilege motion against DG NAB: What lies behind opposition’s rants?

US to Saudi Arabia: No more ‘bombings in Yemen’

Heavy rain in Dubai washes Pakistan’s chance of series win against New Zealand

Has Asia Bibi been transported out of Pakistan?

Brazil will stand with Iran in face of US sanctions: Ex-president

Top Saudis discussed assassinating Iran’s General Soleimani in 2017, sources tell NY Times

No compromise on SC verdict in Aasia Bibi case: PM Imran

Qureshi denies US offered to free Aafia for Raymond, Afridi's release

Why Muhammad Bin Salman hates Iran?

An Indian woman has been seeking treatment for a back injury in Pakistan

Impressed by TLP, will PML-N now use violence against Accountability?

Iran’s master plan to isolate the US

Is Governor Punjab unhappy with CM Buzdar?

Are S-400 in Indian hands a serious threat to Pakistan’s defense?

How Israel helped murder Jamal Khashoggi

Saudi successive failures in al-Hudaydah, why is West looking to end the conflict in Yemen?!

Saudi coalition halts refueling deal with US for Yemen war

Anti-state remarks’ Treason proceedings sought against TLP, JUI-F chiefs

Pilgrims stranded in Iraq sent back to Pakistan: Foreign Office

Would President Trump have mercy on Dr Aafia?

How the 26-year-old Tamil Tiger Insurgency was Defeated

Pakistan comprehensively beat New Zealand by 6 wickets in second ODI

Will Nawaz Sharif and Maryam Safdar be sent to jail again?

Khashoggi killed for disclosing Saudi funding of anti-Iran TV channel: Guardian

Norway suspends licenses for arms export to Saudi Arabia

India to attend meeting with Taliban in Moscow

Quetta: Protest Rally for release of Baluch Student leader Shabir Baluch was stopped to go CM Baluchistan House , Sister and wife of enforced missing student leader broke down in to tears

Lonely prison inmates pin hopes on CJP to bring ‘Adiala’s life’ Nawaz Sharif back home

Opposition not satisfied with Foreign Minister stance on Saudi war on Yemen

Dr. Aafia Siddiqui: victim of ‘extraordinary rendition’

Why Zardari fears arrest?

The Saudi Prince and the growing Iranophobia

Asia Bibi still in Pakistan, Safe & Sound: FO

Fresh Saudi airstrikes leave father, five children dead in Yemen’s Hudaydah

Israeli spyware may have helped Saudi Arabia track, kill Khashoggi: Snowden

2018-11-08 12:44:28

The Myth of Civil Military tensions


Pakistan’s second democratic transition has brought political stability and increased trust of people on national institutions.

People have started participating in the political system and voter turnout was 56 % in July 2018 elections which shows democracy is the preferred system of governance and people want change through the constitutional way.

While there is the change in Pakistan but it is still being seen with jaundiced eyes by our Eastern neighbour India which calls itself secular democracy– but India is procedural democracy as basic democratic values are yet to be part of the national political discourse of India.

India was not accepting that democratic transitions and strengthening of institutions could be part of normal state discourse of Pakistan. Because of India south Asian region is facing strategic instability and now it wants to discredit democratic transition in Pakistan. Past experiences of India’s meddling in other South Asian countries cannot be put side when those countries had to face propped insurgents who destabilized governments.

Dissenting views are the beauty of secular countries but this is yet to be the trademark of Indian society which says its edifice is on secular constitution and values.

While India is having general elections next year and being the largest democracy it must accept the mandate of other democratic countries. Pakistan is as a sovereign state as India is and in Pakistan institutions operate and work as per their established mandate. So India is giving this impression that there is power asymmetry between elected and unelected institutions in Pakistan.

Although Prime Minister Khan made it loud and clear to the domestic and international audience on 6th September this year on Defense and Martyr’s day that myth of civil-military divide must end now. After such statement from country’s chief executive Indian deep state got little space to discredit democracy and Pakistan’s democratic setup. Pakistani society supports its law enforcement agencies for waging and winning the war against terrorism but our national security institutions work under given mandate.

If US military was leading US national security goals in Afghanistan for last 16 years that does not mean its military was in charge of US Congress and it ran US. Same is with Pakistan; if Pakistan’s armed forces have brought peace and stability in the country by leading war on terror and eliminating terrorist elements supported by hostile neighbours, that does not mean that armed forces are working beyond their mandate.

One thing which is alarming for Pakistan and may damage Indian social and political landscape in coming years is emerging nexus of Indian army and ruling party BJP. Recent statements of Indian Army Chief Bipin Rawat that Indian government had taken right decisions after cancelling foreign minister level talks at sidelines of UN shows this nexus is getting deep.

India was not accepting that democratic transitions and strengthening of institutions could be part of normal state discourse of Pakistan.

Army has nothing to do with political decisions as they have to obey rules but hardly local and international media have understood this view of Indian army chief. It seems from this statement that the Indian army has been influencing the Indian government more than their mandate. Right-wing Hindu nationalist party and Indian army have been working to radicalize Indian public against Pakistan.

They use externalization of a threat as sources of domestic unity for India. Meanwhile, Congress will be at a disadvantageous position in next elections because of this BJP and Indian army’s nexus. Whereas human rights bodies including UN has castigated Indian government for compromising human rights, Indian army violates LOC ceasefire agreement and wants to give the impression that LOC clashes are linked with the indigenous struggle of Kashmir.

This is a historical time in Pakistan when all stakeholders from elected and unelected offices are working hand in glove to improve things. Pakistan is part of the transnational Belt and Road Initiative of China where Pakistan will be linked from the Asia Pacific to Europe through land and sea communications. People in Pakistan have given chance to third political force, Pakistan Tehreek –e-Insaf of Imran Khan.

Army has nothing to do with political decisions as they have to obey rules but hardly local and international media have understood this view of Indian army chief.

Status quo has broken and Imran Khan did try to reach India for talks that India refused to because of right-wing Indian media’s pressure and next year general elections. Around the world, no secular state has such a hostile environment where the elected government cannot talk with other elected governments because if they talk and negotiate they will lose next elections but India has to face such an environment.

But yet international community ignores this non-serious attitude of largest democracy which has forced its neighbours for strategic competition and India itself is largest arms importer in the world. Dissenting views are the beauty of secular countries but this is yet to be the trademark of Indian society which says its edifice is on secular constitution and values.

Absences of the positive role of great powers in regional affairs of south Asian states where disputed and unresolved issues like Kashmir are still pending has made millions of people vulnerable. Pakistan wants the world to hold India accountable for its military expenditures, in interfering in other countries domestic affairs and in ending sate sponsor atrocities in Indian occupied Kashmir.

Qamar Cheema

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tags:   pakistan ، India ، PTI ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)