Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India Pipeline
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Belgium knock listless Pakistan out of World Cup

TALIBAN ATTACK ON INTELLIGENCE TEAM NEAR KABUL KILLS AT LEAST 12

AGREEMENT ON PRISONERS SWAP REACHED AT YEMEN TALKS IN SWEDEN

Market watch: Stocks continue to bleed as index drops 545 points

Govt has no right to remain in power if it can't bring back stashed wealth: Fawad

US BLACKLISTS PAKISTAN FOR SUPPRESSION OF RIGHTS OF RELIGIOUS MINORITIES

LEBANESE ISF FOILED MAJOR TERROR ATTACK THRU OPERATION LETHAL CHEESE

IRAQ CELEBRATES NATIONAL HOLIDAY TO MARK FIRST ANNIVERSARY OF DAESH DEFEAT

IRAQ TO SEND DELEGATION TO US TO SEEK SANCTIONS WAIVER FOR IRAN GAS IMPORT

ALLAMA JAVAD NAQVI CONCERNED OVER ENFORCED DISAPPEARANCE OF SHIA MUSLIMS

A doctor of dubious distinctions

NAB goes after Marriyum Aurangzeb: What is the future of PML-N?

Why is the Afghan war unwinnable?

MWM announces support f for PTI candidate in Punjab by-election

5th Gen. War: How Pakistani media played in the hands of enemy?

Nikki Haley’s swansong at the UN was an embarrassment

Pellet Horror In Kashmir

Dr Shireen Mazari criticises HEC for ‘harassing’ foreign degree holders

Three people killed, 12 wounded in France attack

US action may hurt Pak economy

Lack of religious freedom alleged: Pakistan placed on US black list

Democracy, constitution & rule of law: Essentials to take Pakistan forward

Tit for Tat: Canadian ex-diplomat detained in China amid spat over Huawei executive’s detention

Time magazine names Khashoggi 'person of the year'

IS presence in Afghanistan a 'constant threat to Pakistan'

Who is Umm-ul-Baneen?

Govt releases 41pc less funds for development projects

Recent ballistic missile test significant for Iran: Gen. Hajizadeh

US, allies seeking to undermine Iran, Russia

Leader: Outgrowth of Revolution leading to enemy’s defeat

Islam, Humanity and Human Values

Pakistan must not recognize Israel, PLF letter to President and Prime Minister

Hamza Shahbaz's name placed on ECL

Helena Saeed: The first female AIG Police

A formal Arab-USA alliance brewing against Iran

Kashmir boy who acted in Bollywood movie martyred

Is there really a ban on Overseas Pakistanis to bring mobile phone?

Saad Rafique, brother Salman taken into NAB custody in Paragon Housing scam case

100 days not enough to judge performance: Aitzaz Ahsan

PTI to rely on Ordinances: Why is Opposition not happy?

Two Russian nuclear-capable bombers in Venezuela for joint exercises

Peshawar girl to represent country in US Open U-15 squash

PPP questions govt claim of seizing ‘ill-gotten’ £400m abroad

Iran High Council of Human Rights condemns crackdown on French people

THE deadlock appears closer to being broken

Balochistan cabinet shocked by CPEC presentation

EU's Mogherini says promised SPV to Iran to be in place in coming weeks

Weakening external sector: World Bank cancels $250m emergency relief loan

Decision to assassinate Arafat approved by Saudis: Former senior advisor

Persian Gulf kingdom sought to buy Israeli Hermes attack drones: Report

India shifted BLA commander to Afghanistan, claims Dr Jumma Marri

Indian troops martyred 95,238 Kashmiris in IoK since January 1989

India end Australia Test drought in nail-biter

“PM Khan tried to get me killed”: Serious accusation or a hilarious joke?

NO PLACE IN ISRAEL SAFE FROM HIZBULLAH MISSILES: NAIM QASSEM

Is Punjab Government giving special treatment to Shahbaz Sharif?

MYANMAR BECOMES HELL FOR KACHIN CHRISTIANS AFTER ROHINGYA MUSLIMS

DAESH TERRORISTS' RUSSIAN WIDOWS SEEK RETURN TO THEIR COUNTRY

SAUDI FM REJECTS TURKISH DEMAND FOR KHASHOGGI MURDER SUSPECTS’ EXTRADITION

NEW ME SECURITY PACT FOR US ALLIED ARAB REGIMES BEING WORKED OUT

After Trump's letter to Imran, US tirade against Pakistan continues

HOUTHI ANSARULLAH OPEN FOR MORE TALK IF SWEDEN PROCESS YIELDS: SALAM

PAKISTAN FOREIGN MINISTER FORESEES RESTORATION OF US AID

KP CM SEEKS REPORT ON TALIBAN EXTORTION COMPLAINTS

MBS: My strange experience of teaching the Saudi crown prince

PM Imran to review ministries’ performance every three months

PGCC should take Kuwait approach, avoid nonsense: Spox

Asian Classic Power-Lifting: Baig ends Pakistan’s medal wait after 15 years

Allocation of idle LNG capacity to private sector can save $100m

PML-N’s last ditch efforts to save its Quaid

Malaysian PM Mahathir defends PM Khan’s statement on ‘U-turn’

Exposure to air pollution can raise risk of miscarriage, study warns

Imran ‘India’s best bet’ after Pervez Musharraf: ex-Indian spy chief

We lost Test series against New Zealand due to our own mistakes, says Sarfraz

Saudi Arabia rules out extraditing Khashoggi case suspects

US needs ‘puppet’ like Saudi Arabia to achieve global domination: Analyst

Hezbollah: No spot in Israel safe from our missiles

Do not recommend leaving Afghanistan, says US military chief

Speaker Asad Qaisar meets Iranian President, counterpart in Tehran

US accuses Huawei CFO of Iran sanctions cover-up

Atletico, Sevilla go joint top with Barca

Sheikh Rasheed stirs controversy over information portfolio

Now, visa-free travel to this North American country

The deal behind the doors: PML-N looks ready to show flexibility on PAC chairman issue

Larijani: US creating terrorist groups

Punjab Will Have Uniform Syllabus By March 2020

Govt framing national tariff policy to boost exports

Two Iranians nominated for best Asian futsal coach

Over 1,700 arrested in latest 'yellow vest' protests in France

Iran, Russia stress support for private sectors in sanctions era

NAB is an autonomous body: Javed Iqbal

Pakistan may soon clear K-Electric’s sale

PM Imran, President Alvi due in Karachi today

Qatari emir, sultan of Oman not to join PGCC summit in Saudi Arabia

Not a nepotism: Fawad’s brother appointed as Punjab AAG

Who misfed PM Imran Khan?

The Wooing of Jared Kushner: How the Saudis Got a Friend in the White House

Super-Calm Asad Shafiq Equals a Unique Record For Pakistan

Paris in pictures: Burned cars and graffiti littered monuments

Israel authorized sale of spyware to Saudis: Report

2018-10-12 13:29:26

Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India Pipeline

 

 

Till recent, the Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India (TAPI) gas pipeline project was seen as a pipedream, but it has suddenly turned into a reality and apparently its completion is not too far.

 

Lobbyists of the mega-project are painting a rosy picture. They see in it a huge potential, and term it as a vehicle for connectivity and peace, offering sustainable source of energy.

It is argued that contrary to popular belief, instead of being contingent upon Afghan stability, it is likely to become a source of unprecedented peace for Afghanistan. The optimists say that it will create job opportunities for Afghanistan, add gas to dwindling Pakistan’s energy resources, lighten its kitchens, and increase their urea fertilizer production which has a direct bearing on agriculture. TAPI will also bring prosperity to the Indian Punjab.

Turkmenistan which will deliver the gas has invested $ 25 billion, of which $15 billion is for gas field development and $10 billion for laying the pipeline. This project is likely to be completed by 2020, and made operational in 2024. Gas will be provided for next 25 years and its price will be 20% cheaper than Brent crude. Japanese, Chinese, and some other companies have won contracts for gas field and pipeline.

Pakistan will be the third beneficiary since it would also be charging transit fee from India. It is to be determined whether the gas imported from Turkmenistan will be more viable and cheaper or from Iran. India was reluctant to join IPI project owing to security and transit fee issues and was also having similar concerns over TAPI.

TAPI is an energy-based mega project, which provides an alternative market to Turkmenistan’s abundant gas resources. It is hoped that TAPI’s success will attract many Central Asian States and will be a win-win project for all. Apparently, it has the potential to supplement CPEC.

The 56 inches diameter TAPI gas pipeline project will transport 3.2 billion cubic ft of gas annually from the Galkynysh gas fields in Turkmenistan, with 16% earmarked for Afghanistan, and 42% each for Pakistan and India.

 

The 1814 km long TAPI gas pipeline project after passing through Afghanistan (Herat, Farah, Nimroz, Helmand, Kandahar), will enter Pakistan at Chaman. The 820 km long Pakistan section pipeline will traverse through Qila Abdullah, Pishin, Ziarat, Loralai and Musakhel districts in Balochistan; and Dera Ghazi Khan, Muzaffargarh, Multan, Khanewal, Vehari, Pakpattan and Okara districts in Punjab. From Chaman, one branch will veer towards Pasni along Mekran Coast. Pipeline will journey through 17 districts including 8 in Baluchistan and 9 in Punjab. From Punjab, it will then home into India at Fazilka.

Critical Analysis
It is good to be optimistic but optimism should not be at the cost of ignoring ground realities, as well as the fate of Iran-Pakistan-India (IPI) gas pipeline project. While TAPI gas pipeline project surfaced as a Turkmenistan-Afghanistan project in 2006, IPI project came up much earlier, which was signed in 1999.

Iran being next door is economically viable, cost-effective, and secure. TAPI, which is the new version of the pipeline conceived by UNOCOL in 1996, is backed by the USA. Pakistan was in a way coerced to join it asserting that it had far greater benefits than IPI.

Gas will be provided for next 25 years and its price will be 20% cheaper than Brent crude. Japanese, Chinese, and some other companies have won contracts for gas field and pipeline.

The US was averse to IPI because of its rift with Iran, which had been put under sanctions. The US opposed the materialization of the IPI project mainly because it feared that Iran could become an important player once it became a gas supplier for the two major countries of South Asia, and also a strong country because of its nuclear energy program.

The US succeeded in tempting India by offering a civilian nuclear deal in 2006. After signing the nuclear deal in 2008, India stepped out of IPI in 2009. Reasons given by India were the insecurity of gas pipeline passing through Baluchistan which in that timeframe was vulnerable to attacks by Baloch insurgents, and the fear that Pakistan might close the tap to exert pressure on India. In the back of its mind was the possible neutralization of its strategy to blackmail Pakistan through water terrorism.

India had already made a comprehensive plan to destabilize Baluchistan, Mekran Coast, and Karachi by deploying serving Naval Comd Kulbushan Jhadev at Chahbahar in 2003. He was eventually caught in March 2016 and has been awarded death sentence.

The $7.4 billion IPI line envisaged transporting 5.4 Billion cubic feet (Bcf) Iranian natural gas to Pakistan and India. From South Pars, the pipeline stretched over 1,100 km within Iran before entering Pakistan, traveling through Khuzdar. One section was to run through Karachi, and the main section going through Multan to the Indian border (760 km), thereafter travelling 860 km to Delhi.

In 2002, Iran and Pakistan signed an agreement on a feasibility study for Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline. Iran later on proposed an extension of the pipeline into India, with Pakistan standing to benefit from transit fees. The pipeline envisaged supplying 90 and 60 million cubic meters gas per day to India and Pakistan respectively. Despite the delays due to the US pressures, the project remained alive as was evident from the meeting between Gen Musharraf and Ahmadinejad in April 2008, and later on, another meeting in 2012.

Iran being next door is economically viable, cost-effective, and secure. TAPI, which is the new version of the pipeline conceived by UNOCOL in 1996, is backed by the USA. Pakistan was in a way coerced to join it asserting that it had far greater benefits than IPI.

Iran is eager to sell gas because of its transition economy, where unemployment is rising and budget deficits have been a chronic problem. About 18% of the Iran’s population lives below the poverty line and unemployment rate is about 11%. Energy-starved Pakistan is keen to fulfil its energy needs and strengthen its economy. India’s need of energy is much higher, but it remained disinclined, although land-based line from Iran is the cheapest option.

While Pakistan demanded transit fee of 50 cents per MBTU, India wanted it to be 15 cents. China showed interest in joining the IPI project and informed Pakistan that it was keen on importing 1.05 billion cubic feet of gas from Iran through the pipeline if India didn’t participate in the project. China also offered to provide funds to Pakistan to lay the gas pipeline from Nawabshah to connect it with Iranian pipeline. While Iran completed the process of laying pipe inside its territory, Pakistan couldn’t do its bit due to lack of funds, fear of USA, and reservations on gas charges.

Iran kept an inviting tone rather than dictating one with reference to IPI pipeline project. Pakistan was enthusiastic for IPI because of energy shortfall that it faced. While Pakistan was interested because of the transit benefits and lower cost it can enjoy (when compared with prevalent LNG prices), Iran needed foreign exchanges to support the economy. So both Iran and Pakistan didn’t have much bargaining power on the IPI pipeline issue.

India’s security fears were unfounded since Pakistan would never have sabotaged this project because it had its own economic interest in form of transit fee of about $700 million per year. India has made no effort to rejoin the project which is now lying in limbo. The TAPI agreement was signed by Turkmenistan, Afghanistan, and Pakistan at Ashgabat in 2010. The project was held up due to insecurity in Afghanistan.

TAPI project was given a go-ahead signal in February 2018 by four partners including India after settling transit dues and each member promising to contribute $500 million. Saudi backed Asian Development Bank pledged to provide $750 million. Trump administration support the project.

India had already made a comprehensive plan to destabilize Baluchistan, Mekran Coast, and Karachi by deploying serving Naval Comd Kulbushan Jhadev at Chahbahar in 2003. He was eventually caught in March 2016 and has been awarded death sentence.

While Turkmenistan will be the major beneficiary since it would supply gas to three countries, Afghanistan will be next beneficiary since it would earn $420 million royalty per annum. Pakistan will be the third beneficiary since it would also be charging transit fee from India. It is to be determined whether the gas imported from Turkmenistan will be more viable and cheaper or from Iran.

India was reluctant to join IPI project owing to security and transit fee issues and was also having similar concerns over TAPI. Why it has now agreed to join TAPI which involves transit fee from two countries and passage through war-torn Afghanistan and yet to be fully stabilized Baluchistan?

 

Challenges Faced by TAPI
Escalating insurgency in Afghanistan, particularly along the route of the pipeline which passes through Taliban dominated five provinces.
Although Taliban have vowed to protect the mega-project, given its tradition of extortion, each of the five provinces may demand protection money.
Unabated Indo-Pakistan rivalry.
Mutual suspicions and distrust between Afghanistan-Pakistan.
Hot western border and foreign-inspired terrorism in Baluchistan.
ANSF’s inability to contain Taliban insurgency and to protect the pipeline.
The vulnerability of pipeline in Baluchistan to TTP/Daesh attacks.
Implications for Pakistan
Would Pakistan afford to raise another security division to protect pipeline within its territory? Security division for CPEC is funded and equipped by China.
With the opening of TAPI, how Pakistan will be able to block Wagah border for Indo-Afghan trade?
What if the unity regime in Kabul collapses and either the Taliban take over power, or there is a civil war?
Under any of the above possibilities, India is sure to drop out of the project on account of security and also pullout from Afghanistan.
What if Pakistan is unable to pay its share of $500 million due to its financial crisis, or it gets blacklisted by FATF, or it has to pay $ one million daily fine to Iran on account of failing to abide by the terms of IPI agreement?
What will be the future of TAPI if the Iran-Pakistan pipeline project gets completed with China-Russia help? Would Pakistan afford to remain part of CPEC, IP and TAPI simultaneously?
Conclusion. Till such time Afghanistan becomes peaceful and Kashmir issue is resolved, TAPI project will remain a pipedream.

Asif Haroon Raja

Categories:  
Tags:   pakistan ، India ، Afghanistan ، Tapi ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)