America’s Iran Policy Is Helping China Advance a Multipolar World
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Belgium knock listless Pakistan out of World Cup

TALIBAN ATTACK ON INTELLIGENCE TEAM NEAR KABUL KILLS AT LEAST 12

AGREEMENT ON PRISONERS SWAP REACHED AT YEMEN TALKS IN SWEDEN

Market watch: Stocks continue to bleed as index drops 545 points

Govt has no right to remain in power if it can't bring back stashed wealth: Fawad

US BLACKLISTS PAKISTAN FOR SUPPRESSION OF RIGHTS OF RELIGIOUS MINORITIES

LEBANESE ISF FOILED MAJOR TERROR ATTACK THRU OPERATION LETHAL CHEESE

IRAQ CELEBRATES NATIONAL HOLIDAY TO MARK FIRST ANNIVERSARY OF DAESH DEFEAT

IRAQ TO SEND DELEGATION TO US TO SEEK SANCTIONS WAIVER FOR IRAN GAS IMPORT

ALLAMA JAVAD NAQVI CONCERNED OVER ENFORCED DISAPPEARANCE OF SHIA MUSLIMS

A doctor of dubious distinctions

NAB goes after Marriyum Aurangzeb: What is the future of PML-N?

Why is the Afghan war unwinnable?

MWM announces support f for PTI candidate in Punjab by-election

5th Gen. War: How Pakistani media played in the hands of enemy?

Nikki Haley’s swansong at the UN was an embarrassment

Pellet Horror In Kashmir

Dr Shireen Mazari criticises HEC for ‘harassing’ foreign degree holders

Three people killed, 12 wounded in France attack

US action may hurt Pak economy

Lack of religious freedom alleged: Pakistan placed on US black list

Democracy, constitution & rule of law: Essentials to take Pakistan forward

Tit for Tat: Canadian ex-diplomat detained in China amid spat over Huawei executive’s detention

Time magazine names Khashoggi 'person of the year'

IS presence in Afghanistan a 'constant threat to Pakistan'

Who is Umm-ul-Baneen?

Govt releases 41pc less funds for development projects

Recent ballistic missile test significant for Iran: Gen. Hajizadeh

US, allies seeking to undermine Iran, Russia

Leader: Outgrowth of Revolution leading to enemy’s defeat

Islam, Humanity and Human Values

Pakistan must not recognize Israel, PLF letter to President and Prime Minister

Hamza Shahbaz's name placed on ECL

Helena Saeed: The first female AIG Police

A formal Arab-USA alliance brewing against Iran

Kashmir boy who acted in Bollywood movie martyred

Is there really a ban on Overseas Pakistanis to bring mobile phone?

Saad Rafique, brother Salman taken into NAB custody in Paragon Housing scam case

100 days not enough to judge performance: Aitzaz Ahsan

PTI to rely on Ordinances: Why is Opposition not happy?

Two Russian nuclear-capable bombers in Venezuela for joint exercises

Peshawar girl to represent country in US Open U-15 squash

PPP questions govt claim of seizing ‘ill-gotten’ £400m abroad

Iran High Council of Human Rights condemns crackdown on French people

THE deadlock appears closer to being broken

Balochistan cabinet shocked by CPEC presentation

EU's Mogherini says promised SPV to Iran to be in place in coming weeks

Weakening external sector: World Bank cancels $250m emergency relief loan

Decision to assassinate Arafat approved by Saudis: Former senior advisor

Persian Gulf kingdom sought to buy Israeli Hermes attack drones: Report

India shifted BLA commander to Afghanistan, claims Dr Jumma Marri

Indian troops martyred 95,238 Kashmiris in IoK since January 1989

India end Australia Test drought in nail-biter

“PM Khan tried to get me killed”: Serious accusation or a hilarious joke?

NO PLACE IN ISRAEL SAFE FROM HIZBULLAH MISSILES: NAIM QASSEM

Is Punjab Government giving special treatment to Shahbaz Sharif?

MYANMAR BECOMES HELL FOR KACHIN CHRISTIANS AFTER ROHINGYA MUSLIMS

DAESH TERRORISTS' RUSSIAN WIDOWS SEEK RETURN TO THEIR COUNTRY

SAUDI FM REJECTS TURKISH DEMAND FOR KHASHOGGI MURDER SUSPECTS’ EXTRADITION

NEW ME SECURITY PACT FOR US ALLIED ARAB REGIMES BEING WORKED OUT

After Trump's letter to Imran, US tirade against Pakistan continues

HOUTHI ANSARULLAH OPEN FOR MORE TALK IF SWEDEN PROCESS YIELDS: SALAM

PAKISTAN FOREIGN MINISTER FORESEES RESTORATION OF US AID

KP CM SEEKS REPORT ON TALIBAN EXTORTION COMPLAINTS

MBS: My strange experience of teaching the Saudi crown prince

PM Imran to review ministries’ performance every three months

PGCC should take Kuwait approach, avoid nonsense: Spox

Asian Classic Power-Lifting: Baig ends Pakistan’s medal wait after 15 years

Allocation of idle LNG capacity to private sector can save $100m

PML-N’s last ditch efforts to save its Quaid

Malaysian PM Mahathir defends PM Khan’s statement on ‘U-turn’

Exposure to air pollution can raise risk of miscarriage, study warns

Imran ‘India’s best bet’ after Pervez Musharraf: ex-Indian spy chief

We lost Test series against New Zealand due to our own mistakes, says Sarfraz

Saudi Arabia rules out extraditing Khashoggi case suspects

US needs ‘puppet’ like Saudi Arabia to achieve global domination: Analyst

Hezbollah: No spot in Israel safe from our missiles

Do not recommend leaving Afghanistan, says US military chief

Speaker Asad Qaisar meets Iranian President, counterpart in Tehran

US accuses Huawei CFO of Iran sanctions cover-up

Atletico, Sevilla go joint top with Barca

Sheikh Rasheed stirs controversy over information portfolio

Now, visa-free travel to this North American country

The deal behind the doors: PML-N looks ready to show flexibility on PAC chairman issue

Larijani: US creating terrorist groups

Punjab Will Have Uniform Syllabus By March 2020

Govt framing national tariff policy to boost exports

Two Iranians nominated for best Asian futsal coach

Over 1,700 arrested in latest 'yellow vest' protests in France

Iran, Russia stress support for private sectors in sanctions era

NAB is an autonomous body: Javed Iqbal

Pakistan may soon clear K-Electric’s sale

PM Imran, President Alvi due in Karachi today

Qatari emir, sultan of Oman not to join PGCC summit in Saudi Arabia

Not a nepotism: Fawad’s brother appointed as Punjab AAG

Who misfed PM Imran Khan?

The Wooing of Jared Kushner: How the Saudis Got a Friend in the White House

Super-Calm Asad Shafiq Equals a Unique Record For Pakistan

Paris in pictures: Burned cars and graffiti littered monuments

Israel authorized sale of spyware to Saudis: Report

2018-10-05 16:35:45

America’s Iran Policy Is Helping China Advance a Multipolar World

 

The U.S. withdrawal from the Iran deal, and subsequent escalation of tensions between Washington and Tehran presents immediate challenges for China:higher prices for the world’s largest oil importer , a potential conflict along a key juncture in the Belt and Road Initiative, and heightened risk of nuclear proliferation.

Chinese Middle East experts have also raised concerns that overly constrictive U.S. pressure could sideline moderate elements in Tehran, and drive Iran to “adopt a more radical foreign policy ” (采取更激进的外交政策), which would further intensify sectarianism and extremism across an already volatile region.

One day after President Donald Trump announced the Iran Deal withdrawal, an editorial in the Communist Party’s largest official newspaper, the People’s Daily, highlighted a more general Chinese concern that the move heralds a United States shift away from multilateralism towards a more unilateral foreign policy. The editorial appeared under a recurring pen-name “Zhong Sheng” (“voice of China” 钟声) that is used to put forth“quasi-authoritative” positions on key policy issues. The piece castigates the United States for its “Reckless Disregard of International Responsibilities” . The essay observes that by pulling out of the deal, “the US government ignored widespread opposition from the international community” and intensive lobbying from traditional allies. According to “Zhong Sheng,” this willingness to go it alone indicates that U.S. foreign policy is moving “further and further away from multilateralism”

China’s Catch-22, America Unbound, Short-Term Challenge, Long-Term Opportunity

Chinese foreign policy has long sought to facilitate the emergence of a multipolar world . In his 2017 address to the 19th Party Congress, General Secretary Xi Jinping observed that the international system has become more favorable to China as “ trends of global multipolarity ” are “surging forward.”

Beijing’s push for multipolarity is part of a broader effort to erode U.S. primacy. As Robert Blackwill noted , Beijing’s pursuit of “power in all dimensions” is “driven by the conviction that China, a great civilization undone by the hostility of others, could never attain its destiny unless it amassed the power necessary to ward off the hostility of those opposed to this quest.” In order to achieve this goal, China works to build up its own national power, but also seeks to promote the emergence of other poles to counterbalance the United States (Russia, India and Europe). Contrary to some assertions, this not because Beijing seeks to “ rule the world ,” by supplanting the United States’ top spot in the international order (on the contrary, Beijing has demonstrated minimal interest in shouldering the burdens of global leadership). Rather, it is because China sees the United States as the main obstacle to its primary foreign-policy goal, which is to return to its historical position as the dominant power in Asia. Xi made this clear in his speech when he proclaimed that “the Chinese nation now stands tall and firm in the east.”

The emergence of a truly multipolar world order, divided into spheres of influence, would allow China to dominate its East Asian regional environment, and restore what it views as its civilizational birthright as the central country in Asia. Although the world is increasingly multipolar, much of the hardwiring of international system remains under U.S. preponderance (consider the dollar’s continued dominance of international finance; more on this later). One impediment to the emergence of a multipolar world order, is the stubborn persistence of Transatlantic unity, which has prevented the emergence of the European Union (EU) as an alternate, independent pole to U.S. power. As Robert Ross, et al, observe, a more independent European foreign policy would “allow China to capitalize on the emergence of an additional pole in the international system and attempt to play the US and Europe off against each other”.

Even U.S. multilateralism is something of a Catch-22 for China. On the one hand the United States’ global network of alliances and partnerships prevent the emergence of a truly multipolar system. However, on the other hand, these very alliances constrain the United States from acting unilaterally, and condition Washington to adopt a more multilateral foreign-policy approach. Put another way: Beijing wants to facilitate the emergence of a multipolar world, and in the long term, reducing the ability of the United States to act multilaterally with allies would help achieve that goal. But in the short term, the United States turning away from multilateralism and towards unilateralism is deeply threatening to China.

In contrast to Western elites’ alarm over the perceived erosion of global governance systems and the liberal international order in the Trump era, China’s anxiety about a United States that is more nationalistic and prepared to act unilaterally is not primarily normative, but self-interested. Although it would likely become increasingly isolated over time, an America unbound from the constraints of multilateral organizations, pursuing a unilateral foreign policy based on a narrow, transactional conception of its national interests will be a profound challenge to China in the short to medium term. For example, China is already feeling the pinch of U.S. tariffs ( Section 301 ) that the Trump administration has unilaterally imposed outside the framework of the World Trade Organization. Another concern for Beijing is the United States’ ability to inflict economic pain on its adversaries through unilateral sanctions. As Andrew Small of the German Marshall Fund observes, “Beijing has long been keen to see an erosion of U.S. capacity to impose sanctions unilaterally, particularly the sophisticated toolkit that the U.S. Treasury has developed over the last decade.” The recent sanctions that the U.S. Treasury has placed on Chinese enterprises that do business with North Korea and Russia , demonstrate that China is not immune from being a target of U.S. sanctions.

Iran is a Transatlantic Wedge

Some have suggested that U.S.-Europe trade disputes would become a potential Transtatlantic wedge that Beijing could exploit. However, shared U.S. and European grievances towards China’s trade and industrial policies clearly outweigh U.S.-EU differences on trade. This was evidenced this summer, when the United States doubled down on its trade conflict with China by imposing billions of dollars in new tariffs, while at the same time Trump and European Commission chief Jean-Claude Juncker achieved a modus vivendi to “work together toward zero tariffs, zero non-tariff barriers, and zero subsidies on non-auto industrial goods.”

Iran is another matter entirely. Ultimately, the Europeans blame the Trump administration for taking a maximalist approach that sidelines diplomacy in favor of confrontation, a sentiment on full display at this year’s UN General Assembly. French president Emmanuel Macron repudiated Trump’s bellicose speech saying that sanctions and containment are insufficient, “we need to have the space for new negotiations,” and declaiming that “the serious crisis of confidence was opened by the imposition of extraterritorial sanctions by the United States, but Tehran keeps abiding by its nuclear obligation.” At the UN Security Council meeting on nonproliferation, UK Prime Minister Theresa May directly contradicted the Trump administration’s position on Iran, arguing that the JCPOA is the best chance to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons .

China (and Russia) stand to accrue a more immediate practical benefit from the U.S.-Europe Iran rift: the weakening of the United States’ ability to unilaterally impose sanctions. China and the other Iran Deal signatories, the UK, Germany, France and Russia, recently set up a special payments system , which would provide an alternate channel to SWIFT, the primary network for international payments. Although SWIFT is based in Europe, it is beholden to U.S. regulations because of the large number of dollar-denominated transactions it processes. This alternate special-purpose vehicle, which would not involve commercial banks exposed to the U.S. dollar and hence be shielded from potential U.S. retribution, would function as something of a “clearing house” that connected the “Europeans and Iranians as they try to do business.” This demonstrates that the United States’ Iran policy has created an opportunity for China to work with the European powers to begin to slowly chip away at a key lever of UF.S. power—the dollar’s dominant position in the international financial system. Cooperating with Europe enhances China’s efforts to accelerate “de-dollarization” because the Euro is the only currency that is anywhere remotely as internationalized as the dollar. Per SWIFT , as of December 2017, the dollar was used in around 41 percent of international payments, the Euro in 39.45 percent and the RMB in merely 1 percent of transactions.

Of course Iran hawks will respond by decrying that the world does not adequately grasp the dangers posed by Iran. But they cannot deny the reality that most of the United States’ longstanding allies (the UK, France, and Germany) and partners (India) are deeply uncomfortable with the U.S. pressure campaign on Iran. In fact, these allies are so frustrated that they are willing to work with U.S. competitors to blunt Washington’s ability to levy sanctions on its adversaries. With this in mind, the Trump administration needs to undertake a cost benefit analysis on its Iran policy that addresses the following questions. Is it really worth making Iran, a middle power by all accounts, the centerpiece of U.S. foreign policy, especially when this administration has sought to reorient U.S. foreign policy around major power competition? Is it worth alienating longtime allies to take a maximalist approach to Iran? Is it worth imperiling the dollar’s dominance of the international financial system, which hitherto has been a key source of U.S. foreign-policy leverage? If the United States does finds itself in a more serious major-power confrontation with China (for example over Taiwan), or Russia (over Ukraine), then Washington may come to regret that its unilateral approach to Iran alienated allies and eroded a key economic instrument of U.S. power.

 

?

Categories:  
Tags:   India ، China ، US ، Iran ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)