Will Pakistan's daughter Khadija Siddiqi ever find justice
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Govt releases list of Punjab House defaulters owing over Rs60m in payments

Lahore court acquits two suspects involved in murder of Indian spy Sarabjit Singh

Chairman PAC: Who is the real winner?

10 people martyred in Occupied Kashmir by Indian forces

Defenders bad, aggressors good

Iran's FM meets Qatari PM

Shahbaz named PAC chief under opposition pressure: Fawad Chaudhry

Six FC personnel martyred as convoy attacked in Kech district

Pakistan, China and Afghanistan sign MOU on anti-terrorism cooperation

Ittefaq foundry in illegal land occupation: CM Buzdar reveals ill-practices

Iran Intelligence Minister meets Azeri president

SYRIA RECONSTRUCTION TO COST UP TO $400BN: BASHAR AL ASSAD

AMBASSADOR CRITICIZES UN RESOLUTION THAT VIOLATES SYRIAN SOVEREIGNTY

DAESH LOST 44 TERRORISTS IN BU KAMAL, TUNNEL IN NINEVEH IN IRAQ MILITARY RAIDS

CROWN PRINCE MBS WANTS SADAT-LIKE GAME-CHANGING SAUDI ISRAELI SUMMIT

Give up other nationality or quit govt job, SC tells civil servants

Pakistan to host 2020 Asia Cup

NAB to start fresh cases against several politicians

Iran supports Turkish investors’ presence in country

Is the United States really concerned and willing to help Pakistan protect its economy?

Iran's Zarif heads for Qatar

Overcoming gas shortage top priority: Dawood

FMs of China, Pakistan, Afghanistan meet today

No progress made on Balochistan component of CPEC’s western route

US-Taliban talks arranged for Monday: PM

'Yellow Vest' protesters show up in London, block Westminster Bridge

Saudi crown prince considering 'game-changing' handshake with Israeli PM: Report

Hudaydah residents receive first aid packages since recent truce deal

Meet the youngest pellet gun victim in disputed Kashmir

From land mafias to London flats: Whats in store for PML-N?

8 matches of PSL 2019 to be played in Pakistan, final to be held in Karachi

Dar resigns as chief coach after Pakistan's dismal Hockey World Cup performance

Liberal democracy comes to an end: Cleric

SC sends payment schedule decision in cabinet’s court

Aleema Khanum walks away with a fine while Maryam Nawaz was sent to jail – double standards of justice?

Was Maulana Samiul Haq assassinated by his personal secretary?

BBC omits ‘Kulbhushan Yadav’ from Asad Umar’s interview: Influence of India?

Hockey disaster

Usman Buzdar’s maiden presser: Bahria Town, Ittefaq Foundry in illegal state land occupation

ADB sets $7.5 billion lending programme for Pakistan

Sindh threatens to stop gas supply to other provinces

Who approached PTI’s Murad Saeed for an NRO?

BBC says omission of Kulbhushan remark from Asad Umar interview 'not an act of censorship'

Army top brass backs renewed push for Afghan peace

Impasse resolved

Iran to repatriate 1784 clay tablets from US

Iran welcomes initial agreements among Yemenis

‘US wants to help Pakistan protect its economy’

Fitch expects further delay in IMF bailout for Pakistan

Global outcry over INGOs’ closure in Pakistan

NAB lets media inside its lock-ups to counter complaints

Israel won’t succeed if it launches another war on Lebanon, says Hariri

Head of Iran Presidential Office off to Turkey

American military support for Saudi-led Yemen war must stop: US Senate

US and allies rely on defunct resolutions: Zarif

Foreign exchange: SBP reserves fall 3.22%, amount to $7.3b

Iraqi official hails ‘strategic ties’ with Iran

Sarfraz calls on squad to play 'without fear' in South Africa

'Wealth creation' imperative to alleviate poverty: PM

Iran, Japan keen on boosting cultural ties

Ex-Olympians want regime change at PHF after World Cup disaster

'Positive U-turn': PM concedes PAC chairmanship to Shahbaz Sharif 'in the interest of democracy'

US media blocked in Pakistan for spreading propaganda

Lebanon warns against regional consequences of anti-Iran sanctions

Maulana Samiul Haq's personal secretary arrested, labelled person of interest in murder probe

ISRAELIS OF ILLEGAL JEWISH SETTLEMENT CALL FOR MAHMOUD ABBAS MURDER

SANAA AIRPORT REOPENING AGREED UNDER CBM AT SWEDEN TALKS: SOURCES

MIDDLE EAST ROLE WINS SAUDI MONARCHY ISRAELI SUPPORT DESPITE KHASHOGGI MURDER

PRESIDENT ALVI MEETS SAUDI KING SALMAN IN RIYADH

ALLAMA SAJID NAQVI’S GRANDSON RETURNS HOME AFTER 2MONTH ENFORCED DISAPPEARANCE

Allama Sajid Naqvi’s grandson returns home after two month enforced disappearance

Pakpattan JIT: Miseries pile up for Nawaz Sharif

International travellers can get their phones seized at airports

SC orders 20pc reduction in private school fees over Rs5,000

SC forms JIT to probe 'illegal transfer' of Pakpattan shrine land in 1986

Javed Hashmi claims receiving family members’ kidnapping threats: report

TRUMP SNATCHES DEFEAT IN TRADE WAR DUE TO TARIFFS HE IMPOSED

Sanctions not impacting Iran’s trade: Official

Iran urges UNSC to slam US for violating int’l law

Saudi to make biggest foreign investment in Pakistan's history: finance minister

Netanyahu talks of attacking Iran

ICC boss ‘confident’ of corruption-free World Cup

‘Increasing Islamophobia’: FO rejects US religious freedom report

PNS Hangor: Pakistan’s Shark that gave India its costliest naval defeat

Iran, Russia FMs discuss latest Syria developments on phone

Iran remains safe thanks to Islam: Leader

China shares data to check misdeclaration

Pakistan’s power sector causes $18bn loss a year: report

Iran plays down US officials' remarks on renegotiating JCPOA

PM orders inquiry as gas crisis bites

Trump says stands by Saudi crown prince despite rebuke from Senate

China steady on Iran oilfields, to ditch South Pars project: Report

Belgium knock listless Pakistan out of World Cup

TALIBAN ATTACK ON INTELLIGENCE TEAM NEAR KABUL KILLS AT LEAST 12

AGREEMENT ON PRISONERS SWAP REACHED AT YEMEN TALKS IN SWEDEN

Market watch: Stocks continue to bleed as index drops 545 points

Govt has no right to remain in power if it can't bring back stashed wealth: Fawad

US BLACKLISTS PAKISTAN FOR SUPPRESSION OF RIGHTS OF RELIGIOUS MINORITIES

LEBANESE ISF FOILED MAJOR TERROR ATTACK THRU OPERATION LETHAL CHEESE

IRAQ CELEBRATES NATIONAL HOLIDAY TO MARK FIRST ANNIVERSARY OF DAESH DEFEAT

2018-06-12 14:14:02

Will Pakistan's daughter Khadija Siddiqi ever find justice

My decades-long interest in crime shows and movies has a very simple reason. I find it all utterly fascinating: machinations of human mind; the motive; the meticulousness, the audacity in planning and carrying out of a crime; process of investigation — sealing of a crime scene, photographs taken of the body, fingerprint collection, placing of all items around a victim in airtight bags, forensic experts to make their scientific assessments (angle of the attack, weapon that was used, approximate height of the attacker, which hand was used, severity of a stab or a blow in case of a knife or an item that can be used as a weapon) — and an autopsy to ascertain the time, method and physical condition of the body.

A proper investigation starts once a list of suspects is made, and in case of none, the search for a motive and a suspect begins. Everything about the victim is examined in an exhaustive manner without ascribing any importance to anyone’s “character” being of importance to the substance of the crime.

That is what I see in crime shows and movies made in the US, the UK, Europe, Australia, and a Sushmita Sen Indian movie like Samay. What happens in most cases shown in films in Pakistan and India is an eerie reflection of real life: cases are solved on the extraction of a confession from a suspect; investigation is anything but thorough and scientific; a trial is mostly a parody of the real process of presentation of a case by prosecution and defence, and questioning and cross-examining of witnesses; and many sentences are given on the show of influence and power, manifested in myriad forms, of one side.

Many criminals convicted by a court do not finish their sentences, and are released on one concocted pretext or the other; medical reasons are used more than others. In some cases, the sentence is reduced, increasing the agony of a victim or family of a victim; their pain has no expiration date. And in some rare cases, a court nullifies an entire sentence, and a convicted criminal makes a triumphant exit from the court amidst cheers, making a victory sign, showing a middle finger to the victim’s family and the moral fibre of a society, tightly hugged by a father who is a lawyer, representing everything that is wrong and shameful about one of the most scared of human institutions: a court of law.

Khadija Siddiqi. This name has become synonymous with much that is a representation of the social, moral and legal character of the country I call home, the country I love like no other, the country that I look at as my safe place. Today, a day before another hearing of Khadija, my mind grapples with question marks, ellipses and incongruities that are presented as a moral and legal defence against a victim of violence.

Khadija is a 23-year-old young woman who on Friday took the last paper of her final year law examination, and for whom the venerable institution of law is higher than any other means of public service. Assaulted with a knife, stabbed 23 times, in broad daylight, on one of the busiest roads of Lahore, Khadija became a victim of violence two years ago. She was 21, accompanied by her then six-year-old sister, and assaulted in, what would appear to any horrified onlooker, an attempt to kill. Her attacker was her class fellow, Shah Hussain.

Today, two years later, after a prolonged saga of a pre-arrest bail, an insufficient police investigation, outrage on social and electronic media against lack of justice, harassment cloaked in legalities of the defence team, dilly-dallying under one legal pretext or the other, the 2017 sentencing of seven years of the accused, Shah Hussain, reduction of sentence to five years by a sessions court, an appeal from Khadija’s side to repeal the order of reduction of sentence, and an appeal from the accused’s side to reconsider the very basis of the sentence, the situation is back to square one.

On June 4, the Lahore High Court announced Shah Hussain’s acquittal. Yes, acquittal. The word is not a typo, it is a High Court verdict. And while Khadija, stunned, traumatised, announced her resolve to keep fighting, strengthened by the determination of her lawyer, Hassaan Niazi and his team, and supported by almost all sections of society, including politicians, celebrities, activists, media persons, intellectuals, students and human rights organisations, the verdict lays bare the darkness of some realities all of us as individuals, as practitioners of law and as a society must examine with a great deal of introspection and soul-searching. It all begins with the gender of the victim. Khadija’s gender, it appears, is her primary “crime”.

The 12-page High Court verdict that I read is a documentation of many things despite being merely a legal decision: a shoddy police investigation, a weak case of prosecution (as per the High Court), insufficient evidence and “unreliable” testimonies of witnesses, and most importantly, the “credibility” of the victim. The judge stated that he is “forced to disbelieve the injured prosecution witnesses,” while stressing the rarity of his stance as “the injured witness is not normally disbelieved”.

Apparently, Khadija was “disbelieved”. The “disbelieving” began with the premise that a young man could not take rejection and attack her fatally.

The judge further noted that Khadija, the victim and “injured eyewitness” had “not described the true/complete tale,” and that the attack “may have taken place, but not in the manner as described by the eye/injured witnesses… Evidence of eye/injured witnesses, thus, could not be relied upon with any amount of confidence.”

As per the judge, Khadija had simply no reason to depose that Shah Hussain used to harass her keeping in mind the fact that she had written “a letter of four pages […] proposing him for marriage” and had “never complained [to college authorities or her parents] against the petitioner for any misconduct or harassment”. The judge further ruled that he was unable to believe her testimony as “the motive set up by the prosecution comes to the ground”.

The judgement also states: “…Mere presence of injuries would not stamp out that she [the witness] is a truthful witness,” and that “it is not a universal rule that each and every word coming from the mouth of the injured person is truth.”

As a patriotic citizen of Pakistan, and as someone who believes in the sanctity of law, I read the verdict with a growing unease, a nagging feeling of sadness. Myriad questions arise in my mind, apart from the staggering weaknesses in the existing investigation and legal system — with due respect to the honourable High Court of Lahore.

Is the Khadija Siddiqi case a reminder to take a deep, hard look at the inherent sexism, gender inequality and misogynistic ethos of our patriarchal society, diabolic in blatant violent attacks on the “weaker sex”, the “second class citizen,” at times, and couched in presentation of females as unreliable witnesses sometimes? Does a woman’s “character”- in Khadija’s case, her mere photographs with her male class-fellows in company of other people – become the weapon with which to destroy the defence that is presented in her case of being a victim of violence? When she is not seeking any monetary compensation, what is the motive attributed to her pursuit of justice?

When Khadija’s attacker and his family do not show a shred of remorse, and the attacker is set free because of his father’s considerable influence as a lawyer among his brotherhood of likeminded lawyers, why is the victim made to feel like a criminal? In order not to punish with even a shred of doubt an “innocent” man — Shah Hussain — why is Khadija’s testimony, her several scars of knife-stabs, and her long battle putting her life on hold, under so much doubt to prove the authenticity of her ordeal, her ongoing trauma?

In response to public and media uproar, the honourable Chief Justice of Pakistan, Mian Saqib Nisar, taking suo motu notice of the High Court verdict of Shah Hussain’s acquittal has issued a directive: The Supreme Court Registry in Lahore, on June 10, 2018, will hear the Khadija case.

And while I wait for the court to do its job, I have these recurring thoughts: if Khadija was stabbed 11 times and not 23 times, if she could not name her attacker right away, if she “liked” the attacker once upon a time, and if the stabs on her neck did not kill her, does she not as a citizen of Pakistan deserve that justice be done to her?

Who will do justice to Khadija Siddiqi?

Mehr Tarar

Categories:  
Tags:   pakistan ، US ، UK ، Khadija Siddiqui ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)