Kashmir and Palestine are punchbags for their occupiers
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS

Saudi Arabia invited to become third strategic partner in CPEC: Fawad Chaudhry

Bannon: Saudi, Egypt, UAE prepared to occupy Qatar

Talks again: Positive overtures between Modi and Khan

Shafaqna Exclusive: The deal behind Nawaz Sharif's release

Religious affairs minister discusses treatment of Xinjiang Muslims with Chinese envoy

US envoy says Washington seeks a treaty with Iran

'Saudis gave MKO gold, Rolex watches worth hundreds of millions of dollars'

India outclass Pakistan in one-sided Asia Cup affair

What happens next after IHC orders Nawaz Sharif's release?

Sentences of Nawaz Sharif, Maryam Nawaz, Capt Safdar suspended

CJP takes notice of 10-year-old Amal’s death in Karachi

Is Saudia paying $2bn for Nawaz Sharif's safe passage?

The Man Behind Imran Khan

Video: Who Hussain is and why Shia Muslims mourn for him?

Lives of hundreds of thousands of Yemeni children hang in balance

Why IMF looks unavoidable?

Sarfraz, Rohit promise blockbuster India-Pakistan clash

ICC launches investigation into Myanmar’s crimes against Rohingya Muslims

Afghanistan arrests over two dozen Daesh terrorists ahead of Ashura

Motives behind Saudi largesse: Is Bin Salman wooing Imran Khan with Petr-dollars?

Azadars under attack by terrorists in Ratto Dero Larkana

Sarfraz bats for Indo-Pak series on home soil

Farhan Junejo, close aide of late PPP leader, reportedly arrested in UK

Democrats planning to stop Trump’s military support for Saudi war on Yemen

Can India and Pakistan cooperate on water?

CTD Punjab ‘breaks’ TTP, Hizbul Ahrar network

Pakistan's Imran Khan vows to give citizenship to some Afghans, Bengalis

NATO warships moving closer to Syria shores amid looming US airstrikes: Report

29th Annual Ashura Day Procession in London to be held on Thursday

Number of prisoners of conscience in Saudi Arabia increases to 2,613

US always has a political bias against Muslims, says Minister Shireen Mazari

Pakistan Embassy commemorates Defence Day in Tehran

Run out/match ratio: Pakistan remains best fielding side in ODIs in last two years

Pakistan, UK reach agreement on repatriation of 'looted wealth'

Manzoor Pashteen, PTM leader – declared a proclaimed offender

China struggles with Belt and Road pushback

PPP warns of strong ‘resistance’ if Kalabagh dam project is revived

Yemeni forces shoot down Saudi spy drone in Jizan

Iran says Saudis, UAE turned OPEC into “tool” for US

Pakistani Student Wins Award for Improving LTE & 5G Wireless Systems

Outlawed Sipah-e-Sahaba threatens shopkeepers over Nohas in Hub city

A massive paradigm shift: US envoy claims Pakistan ready to open Afghan land route for India: US envoy

South Asia Cup: Pakistan takes on Hong Kong today

Indian army has crossed all limits of cruelty in Indian Occupied Kashmir

Mismatch between Imran Khan’s words and Punjab govt’s deeds!

New laws: Opposing Dam can be treason in Pakistan

A proactive foreign policy: Can Pakistan replace India in Afghanistan?

Iran envoy: World should take MI6's Syria plot seriously

Syrian military downs Israeli missiles fired at Damascus airport

Freedom of speech and blasphemous caricatures

Iran envoy speaks at National Defense University on Pak-Iran strategic cooperation

Malik Riaz of Bahria Town extends sincere apologies to Shia Muslims

UK legislators’ team rejects plea for Ishaq Dar’s deportation

Turkey pledges to support Pakistan on Kashmir at UN

Medical, dental colleges’ entry test on September 23

Bilateralism between India and Pakistan

Israeli forces fatally shoot three Palestinians in Gaza

Not my fault that I'm Inzamam’s nephew: Imam-ul-Haq

Saudi Arabia holds religious oppression as a normalized system of governance

Senior UAE official pays secret visit to Israel: Report

Taliban for minus Pakistan talks with US administration

Youm-e-Ali Asghar observed to commemorate Imam Hussain’s infant

Begum Kulsoom Nawaz's funeral

Un-poisoning the chalice!

World’s longest straight-line sea route connects Pakistan to Russia

CPEC: Exposed to hybrid warfare

Spain gives in to Saudi pressure to deliver 400 precision bombs

Saudi forces tear down Muharram mourning tents in Shia Qatif region

Saudi Arabia buys Israeli ‘Iron Dome’ system amid détente: Report

Syrians dodge death with air strike warning app

Four senior Shia Islamic scholars gagged as no change seen under PTI govt

Kulsoom Nawaz’s funeral prayers held in London

Mini budget Bomb: Govt to impose new taxes of Rs400bn

India beat Pakistan 3-1 to reach SAFF final

Prime Minister House to be converted into high-quality postgraduate institute: minister

Dam Mania: Can Pakistan go for Kala Bagh dam?

An old Mantra: Is US planning again to control Pakistan nukes?

India’s push on Iran's Chabahar puts US in tight corner

Pompeo appreciates Saudi respect for civilians in Yemen war, lets aid continue

Official: UAE convinced Yemen’s Saleh to ally with Houthis

Sharifs' Raiwind residence declared sub-jail as Nawaz, Maryam parole extended by three days

High security needed in Moharram due to threat of terrorism

Will Imran Khan continue support with Saudi led military coalition?

A hope for a better education system

Pompeo said US would not block Pakistan if it seeks IMF bailout: Fawad Chaudhry

PM Imran Khan forms task force on sports

At key ‘2+2’ talks, India should take US demands on Iran oil sanctions with a pinch of salt

Govt allows Nawaz Sharif, Maryam to attend Kulsoom funeral in Lahore on parole

Bus crash in India's Telangana state kills at least 53

UK urged to relax rules on foreign students

Suicide bomber kills 32 in Afghanistan’s Nangarhar province

Sindh education dept orders private schools to return extra fees

Election Commission rejects petition against renamed banned terrorist outfit PRHP

Wife of Ex-Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif passes away in London after long battle with cancer

Is ‘South Punjab’ possible?

Sarfraz wants Pakistan to post 300-plus in every Asia Cup game

Turkic Muslims: China and the Muslim world’s Achilles heel

Pakistan, China react angrily to Financial Times report on CPEC

Gen Bajwa donates Rs1bn for dam fund on military's behalf

Ahmad Shah Massoud: Legacy of Lion of Panjshir

2018-01-10 08:43:20

Kashmir and Palestine are punchbags for their occupiers


Kashmir and Palestine are two nations with too long a history but too small a geography. A history of mass-historical blunders; of occupation and oppression; of resistance and rebellion; of angst and determination; of hope and despair; of nation and nationhood; and of belief and belongings.


A geography whose walls of blood and horror are viewed as an exhibit in a case by outsiders but have no windows to the outside world; an odd conjecture yet fitting for Kashmir and Palestine. What broadly connects the two nations and elucidates their otherwise fairly indifferent marginal existence is their mutual expression of “Resistance against Occupation”. With the Palestinian struggle being recognised the world over, Kashmir remains peevishly in the margins of 18 UN Security Council Resolutions like an abject letter bearing an unknown address.


Although the din of death is heard constantly in Kashmir, the people have kept supporting the Palestinian freedom struggle persuasively but persistently, primarily because both territories have been pierced by occupation. Furthermore, Kashmir is a predominantly Muslim area and most Kashmiris associate themselves with Palestine for the religious sanctity it embodies within Islam. The former Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Shaikh Amin Al-Husseini, was a staunch critic of India’s claim over Kashmir, reflecting reciprocity from Palestinians. Kashmiri poet Uzma Falak argues that Palestinians have travelled and fought in Kashmir against Indian occupation. Despite the geo-political realities, the voracious and indiscriminate bond of brotherhood and solidarity adorns the walls in Kashmir with graffiti such as “Save Gaza, free Palestine”, “Freedom: from Al-Aqsa to Kashmir”, and vice-versa. No matter how bestial the enemy is, the determination to resist confirms that Kashmiris and Palestinians have always eviscerated the occupiers because their faith in their struggle is greater than the fear institutionalised by the occupation.


The relationship between those occupiers, India and Israel, is described by analysts as a “full-blown romance” and has dominated the news and international politics much more than the territories they are occupying illegally. The overt-covert, official-unofficial overtures between the two are stirring up a hornet’s nest, with serious ramifications, particularly for the Middle East and Global South Asia. The relationship between them has a commonality in links with the US, and the axis largely bears the imprint of American interests in the region. To undermine the growing economic influence of China, the US pursues its containment policy meticulously by pushing American and Israeli economic interests in the Indian markets. Israel is the largest beneficiary of US aid and this comes with its own terms and conditions. It generally spends this aid on technology, capacity building and the development of its military-industrial complex; the fruit of this is then sold on to the Indian government through defence agreements. Pakistan, of course, is the elephant in the room, and apprehension about this nuclear power is a shared concern of all three. In every scenario, though, the US dominates the political chessboard of arms and aid in this part of the world.


The 9/11 attacks on the US mainland caused unexpected paradigmatic shifts in international politics, leading to extreme vetting of joint cooperation and revamped pledges of allegiance to new holy-unholy alliances. In an unpleasantly disparaging gesture, US-Israel-India became natural allies overnight; suddenly, being critical of, or showing resentment towards this axis meant being viewed as hostile towards secular-progressive-democratic forces in the world. The shift in diplomatic nomenclature and the orientation of attitudes between Israel and India have changed drastically in recent years.


This odd farrago between India and Israel reveals historical conformities with a dash of deep-state lobbying. In 1968, India started to engage with Israel through its newly-created intelligence agency called the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW). The then director of RAW, R.N. Kao, established healthy connections with Israel’s Mossad spy agency at the behest of Prime Minister Indira Ghandi. Since independence in 1947, India had maintained frequent contacts with Arab states to meet its trade and energy requirements; with an economy that was not just stumbling but stuttering, New Delhi fostered soft power and kept its economic stakes alive with the Arab world. India continued rather cleverly to avoid diplomatic relations with Israel at an official level, but allowed the RAW-Mossad nexus to keep growing, so much so that Israeli General Moshe Dayan regularly met RAW spymasters in Nepal. The Indian government had hardly opened its markets and adopted a policy of economic liberalisation when it dropped its “damned and doomed approach” and ties with Israel were normalised; the first Israeli Embassy was opened in Delhi in 1992.


The post-Cold War realities reduced the dilemmas and political complexities in both countries and contacts between them unfolded in real time, vindicating the pivotal role played by shadow diplomacy in the establishment of formal ties. Initially, India ruled out any defence and security deals with Israel, such as the purchase of “remotely piloted vehicles” (RPVs) in 1994 by the defence research and development organisation (DRDO), but in his book “Indo-Russian relations: problems, prospects and Russia today”, author V.D. Chopra states explicitly that “all the first fifty meetings [between the Indians and Israelis] were about defence cooperation and the subject matter was deliberately kept secret by India”. In the defence, security and intelligence sectors, the strategic cooperation between the two reigned supreme. Israel defence company Soltam supplied India with its Green Pine radar system that monitors and intercepts ballistic missiles as well as its night vision systems, which played a major role in the Kargil War with Pakistan in 1999.


In a bid to build up its military capabilities, India has purchased defence-related equipment and services from Israel worth more than $10 billion and has become the largest importer of Israeli arms. It has purchased more drones from Israel than anyone else in the past decade, and uses them in Kashmir. Declining a US offer of Javelin missiles, India instead closed a $525 million deal with Rafael Advanced Defence Systems to buy Spike anti-tank guided missiles. Israel has also provided upgraded cyber security systems to India, which are on full display in Kashmir and its north-east states.


With populist politics on the rise in major democratic nations, democracy itself seems to be on its knees and reveals an inherent weakness when the values it claims to uphold are so often abandoned in practice. While showcasing a democratic outlook, India and Israel have no compunction about simultaneously criminalising legitimate dissent in the territories they occupy. Amnesty international and Human Rights Watch reports confirm that, “In Kashmir, India unleashes its military might and stifles the dissent by taking recourse to draconian laws like the AFSPA (Armed Forces Special Powers Act) and PSA (Public Safety Act).” In Palestine, meanwhile, Israel invokes its brutal “military order 101”. Both India and Israel quickly jumped on the global war on terror bandwagon and seized the moment to link resistance in the occupied territories with “terrorism” and “Islamic fundamentalism”; in the meantime, both are unabashed about their own war crimes and human rights violations.


All at once, India is one thing and many things. It recognises and supports the Palestinian cause but summarily remains complicit in illegal Israeli settlements and abstains from UNHRC votes to avoid conducting an enquiry into Israel’s human rights violations, for which the Israeli Ambassador in New Delhi, Daniel Cameron, thanked India for not getting involved in some international Israel bashing. The Economist report on “Netanyahu pivots to Asia” concedes that Indian diplomats once asked their Israeli counterparts, “Why should Israel care about votes in the UN when India is buying $7 billion of Israeli arms?” In international forums, India accepts that Kashmir is a dispute with Pakistan, to be settled mutually by taking the pro-freedom Kashmiri leadership into its confidence. However, with false pride and nationalistic snobbery, New Delhi evades the Kashmir issue in every bilateral forum with Pakistan by referring to it as a domestic issue and a simple matter of law and order. To Indian citizens, Kashmir is projected as an integral part of the state and then brushed under the carpet as a matter of national security. Other than rose-tinted, romanticised adventures, Kashmir usually remains off the negotiation table.


Ever since the BJP came into power in India as a right-wing nationalist party with proven fascist tendencies, the political climate and social fabric has received a series of blows. The party has institutionalised force by making fear pervasive, resulting in an unprecedented surge in Islamophobic incidents across the country. The BJP’s politics depends on a majoritarian-Hindutva narrative, and uses Islamophobia as a tool for political subjugation. The anti-Muslim, anti-minority and anti-intellectual prejudice permeates political life extensively, from the counter terrorism policy pursued by the state to the tacit approval it has given to cow-vigilantes who have committed some harrowing crimes in the past three years. In style and character, the power structure and subsequent consolidation trend is quite similar to that followed by Israel against the Palestinians. This utter disregard for human brotherhood, dignity, equality, liberty and freedom reveals how both countries are making a mockery of open government and how the global advocates of democracy maintain a criminal silence to protect their own economic and national interests.




Tags:   India ، Israel ، Palestine ، Kashmir ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)