JIT Report: Top 10 legal minds on what next
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Donald Trump : A president or a goon?

Abbasi shakes UN by bold address: Pakistan won't be a 'scapegoat' in Afghan war

Show of poor diplomacy: A wrong message to US

Collapse of Iran deal would send a 'terrible signal': Germany

Egypt’s Sisi urges Palestinians to unite, co-exist with Israelis

UAE and Saudi Arabia to normalize their secret relations with Israel

Dodging accountability courts: Did establishment give a safe passage to Nawaz Sharif?

Netanyahu Says Trump Promised to ‘Fix’ Iran Deal

Free Balochistan: An insider to heavily funded Indian campaign against Pakistan

95,000 patients waiting for unknown fate from the continued closure of Sanaa airport

Brutal lynching: Can Pakistan courts provide Justice to Mashal Khan?

Hamza bin Laden: the heir to al Qaeda?

Why has a UK team genetically edited human embryos?

How Russia came to Pakistan’s help?

Defying Courts: What is next for Nawaz Sharif?

Such TV | Rouhani censures Trump’s anti-Iran rhetoric

President Trump calls for a holocaust on the floor of the United Nations

Iran infiltrated US military, obtained proof of ISIS collusion

Saudi plan to ‘accept Israel as a brotherly state’

United States supplying weapons worth $2.2B to Syrian terrorists organization

LUBP | How dishonest “Social Justice Warriors” work to curb the religious freedoms of targeted groups

“Go Nawaz Go” Makes it to Speed Test Server!

UAE ambassador to Ankara threatens Turkey to close down its embassy

Saudi Arabia's king-in-waiting cements grip on power with charm and crackdowns

US paradoxes and Pakistan’s war against terrorism

Free Balochistan: A joint venture of RAW and CIA to burry CPEC

Confidential U.N. report accuses Saudi coalition of killing hundreds of Yemeni kids

Pakistani teenager develops anti-BlueWhale app

UAE’s ambassador to the U.S considers Saudi Arabia responsible for the ruining of the UAE’s good name

Rabbani seeks official response on anti-Pakistan posters in Switzerland

Nawaz Sharif must not appear before NAB court: Maryam

Trump says if threatened, US will 'totally destroy' North Korea

EXCLUSIVE – Interview with Dr. S.M. Kazem Mesbah Mousavi, Imam Ali Centre Canada

More than 800 Shia pilgrims have to stay at Taftan border for a week

Five eminent Shia scholars banned from entering Gilgit under unjust policy of balance

57 accused charge-sheeted in Mashal Khan lynching case

Nisar lashes out at Khaqan Abbasi, Asif for statements on ‘internal matters’

Pakistan team kicks off training, ahead of Sri Lanka series in UAE

Bank of China permitted to start operations in Pakistan

Pakistan protests with Switzerland over ‘Free Balochistan’ posters

Nawaz Sharif, children fail to appear in court; summons reissued

US paradoxes and Pakistan’s war against terrorism

Saudi plan to ‘accept Israel as a brotherly state’

Was NA-120 election rigged?

UAE ambassador to Ankara threatens Turkey to close down its embassy

Saudi Arabia's king-in-waiting cements grip on power with charm and crackdowns

Confidential U.N. report accuses Saudi coalition of killing hundreds of Yemeni kids

Pakistani teenager develops anti-BlueWhale app

US’ Black Hawk Down in Yemen

Outrage in Egypt over Israeli Flag in educational book

Russo-Saudi closeness: What are two sides’ goals?

Arrest warrants: Should Imran Khan present himself before ECP?

Is Establishment pulling NAB’s strings?

How CIA and Raw are funding Pakistani separatists: An Inside story

An old desire: Is Gov trying to place ISI under civilian control?

Certain Western states still back terror groups in Syria: Assad

Iran, Pakistan army chiefs urge Muslim world action to end Rohingya plight

Iraq vice president: Baghdad won't tolerate creation of ‘second Israel’

Myanmar says US official barred from Rohingya conflict zone

Iraq’s Nujaba Movement condemns terrorist attacks in Nasiriyah

Unofficial results show PML-N’s Kulsoom set to win NA-120 by-election

Is China using North Korea to break US's Super power's myth?

US Plan for New Afghan Force Poses Threat to Civilians

UK arms sales benefiting most from Middle East wars

UAE: Saudi Arabia was going to launch military attack on Qatar

US policy shift: Would Pakistan turn into another Iran for US?

Has Trump become a leader of Arab nationalism?

Is Gwadar a toll plaza?

Would a defeat in NA-120 would end PML-N's politics from Punjab?

Rohingyas of Karachi struggle to deal with identity crisis

Guilt of war crimes: Suicide among US war veterans highest in west

Saudi Crown Prince Calls Off Visit to Paris for Fear of Popular Uprising

Iqna | Georgian Muslim Cleric Urges Boycotting Myanmar to End Massacre of Rohingya

Mehr News | ‘Saudi Arabia, Taliban like brothers’

Such TV | JUIF rejects hiring educated imams in KP mosques

Why US is not happy with Deir Ez-Zor’s recapture from ISIS?

The United States and Russia rejected the request of Israel to keep Iran far from the Syrian border

Netanyahu is the Israeli Trump

Paradiagm shift: Pakistan’s big ‘No” to US aid

Did PML-N verbal attacks on Judiciary affected the Panama review appeal?

Saudi Arabia, Sudan banned from Labour party conference

Kulbhoshan Yadav’s case: Why ICJ will not give decision in favor of Pakistan?

Why emergence of Hafiz Saeed linked-MML in Pakistani politics is almost inevitable

UNICEF says 240,000 Rohingya kids in dangerous situation

We will sink Japan and turn US to 'ashes and darkness', says North Korea

Pakistan Still Hasn’t Received Trump’s Demand List

Saudi security: detained preachers are members of spying cell

Russia urges Syria not to retaliate against Israel airstrike

Controversial Saudi Prince detained

Facts hidden by the UAE about its military aircraft crashed in Yemen and the fate of its crew

‘Blue Whale’ taking a bite out of K-P

Who is pressurising NAB to file appeal in Hudaibiya case?

China Backs UN Call for Justice in Yemen; US, Saudis Object to Move

Deepening rift: Would PML-N meet the same fate of MQM?

A dangerous tactics: Why Daesh is targeting IT experts from Pakistan universities?

Ansarullah missiles can reach anywhere in UAE: Houthi

Iran a partner in Syrian victory: Assad's letter to Ayatollah Khamenei

MEHR | Saudi Arabia, Israel paving way for US military presence on China border

LUBP | All Deobandi-Salafi right wings parties are on same Page

Pakistan is Among Bottom 5 Countries for Education & Skills Development

2017-07-17 07:23:26

JIT Report: Top 10 legal minds on what next

 

As the country awaits the result of Joint Investigation Team’s report on the assets of Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif’s family after it has been furnished with the Supreme Court Implementation Bench, senior legal minds differ on the procedure to be adopted next.

 

Some are of view that the Implementation Bench will examine the JIT report, issue notices to the parties and decide the case, while a few say the report is for the satisfaction of judges only and they can decide on their own after the report comes before them.

 

Some senior lawyers and legal minds are of view that the Implementation Bench will send the JIT report to the chief justice who will refer it back to the five-member bench of the Panama case to decide the matter.

 

A few also hold that the CJ can constitute a new bench once the JIT report comes to him or the matter is referred to him.

 

 

Talking to The News about the next process of the case after the JIT report, eminent lawyer and constitutional expert Abid Hassan Manto said it was up to the apex court to decide whether to continue hearing by itself or refer the case to a trial court.

 

 

I am not sure about what the Supreme Court decides. It is fully empowered to hear the case by itself or it can even refer it to any accountability or trial court,” he said.

 

Salman Akram Raja, Advocate Supreme Court, said the three judges of the Implementation Bench will decide the case.

 

 

They can dispose of the case, they can send a reference, they can pass an order, or they can refer the case to the chief justice for further action, he said.

He said a bench of the SC could pass any order. He said the Implementation Bench was a fully-fledged bench of the SC; therefore, it can pass any order and decide the case in hand.

———————————-

 

Senior Advocate Supreme Court Akram Sheikh said the chief Justice of Pakistan had formed the Implementation Bench based on the judgment of 20th April and in all those cases where commissions were formed, the report of the commission was presented to the court and all the parties were issued notices and the report was always subject to cross-examination.

 

 

He said the JIT report could be sent to the chief justice who will decide which bench should hear the case and in his opinion the case could not go to the same 5-member bench of the SC because two among them had already opined on the case; therefore, either a new bench or a larger bench would be formed, as it was entirely up to the CJ to decide.

 

 

Akram Sheikh said it was the jurisdiction of the chief justice to refer the matter to either the same three judges, or form a new bench to decide the fate of the JIT report.

———————————-

 

Justice (R) Wajiuddin Ahmad explained the procedure that three judges of the five-member bench in Panama Papers case had requested the chief justice to form an implementation bench for their judgment of further probe into the affairs of Sharif family. The CJ formed a three-member bench comprising the same three judges. Now the report would be sent to the chief justice.

 

“Normally, the CJ has the powers to form benches but in cases where a judgment has already been passed, the CJ has no powers to change the bench; therefore, the CJ is bound to send the JIT report to the five judges of Panama Papers case who had earlier given a verdict on April 20th”, said the retired judge adding, “Those five judges will then decide about the case. Either the two judges who had said that the PM stands disqualified might change their judgement as they would have an option or the three judges who ordered further investigation would take a decision regarding the PM’s disqualification”.

———————————-

 

Senior lawyer and former Attorney General for Pakistan Irfan Qadir said the two judges had given their decision in the case while three had not given any verdict; therefore, when a verdict has not come forth it cannot be implemented. All what is happening is a bench is facilitating an investigation through the JIT because had there been any decision there would have been its execution which is not the case.

He was of the view that the CJ must form a larger bench to decide the matter of disqualification through courts under Article 184(3) of the Constitution.

“The larger bench will have to revisit past precedents where people were disqualified from being MPs through courts while it was not the duty of courts to disqualify an MP and by this way court will purify itself”, the lawyer held.

———————————-

 

SCBA President Rasheed A Rizvi said the three-judge bench was in fact an implementation bench for order of the court passed on 20th April; therefore, after the JIT report all the parties had been issued notices and the issue will again land before the five-member bench to decide the case. Rizvi was of the view that the JIT report will be subject to cross-examination.

———————————-

Babar Sattar said the three-member bench of the SC had to determine the fate of the case before them after considering the JIT report and call for objections if anyone had.

He said the original five-member bench of the SC had given its final verdict of which two judges had said that the PM stood disqualified while three ordered a thorough inquiry into the allegations against the PM’s family.

“It was not necessary that the three judges of the Panama Case Bench were to become members of the implementation bench but the chief Justice constituted the bench and included the same three judges in the implementation bench otherwise it’s a whole new bench of the SC whose aim is to implement the judgment of 20th April,” said Babar Sattar.

———————————-

 

Barrister Ali Zafar, senior advocate and ex-president of SCBA, said it was a settled principle that there would not be an immediate decision on the JIT report and on the principle of fair trial replies from the parties had been sought and after those replies a decision would be taken. He mentioned that it may take another 30 days for the bench to pronounce a decision on JIT report.

———————————-

 

Senior Advocate SC Ikram Chaudhry said one thing must be kept in mind that it was an Implementation Bench which was hearing the case; therefore, it has to take a decision on the JIT report.

 

“There is no need for further trail, as the JIT is working for the satisfaction of three judges who had ordered in April 20 judgment that a further probe is required into Sharif family’s monetary affairs in order to get a clear picture whether the prime minister stands disqualified or not, and if anyone of these judges says that Nawaz Sharif is disqualified, the April 20th Judgement will become 3- 2majoritywith three judges saying PM stands disqualified”, said the senior lawyer.

———————————-

 

Azhar Siddique Advocate Supreme Court said the three-member Implementation Bench will examine the JIT report and could summon the prime minister if necessary and may order his disqualification.

 

This has been written in the para four of the April 20th judgment that the bench can disqualify the PM if it is satisfied with the JIT’s report. The issue can be referred to the 5-member bench of panama papers case only to the extent of sending a reference against the accused persons.

 

The News

pk.shafaqna.com

 

 

Categories:  
From other agencies (RSS Reader)

Press agenda on September 22

- worldbulletin.net

Threat decoded

- BBC Asia