A Shiite perspective on political systems in Iraq – By Ayatollah Sayyid Jafar al-Hakim
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Shoe thrown at Ahsan Iqbal during speech

Zardari defends government for sending Pakistani troops to Saudi Arabia

Pakistan could evict, rather than kill, militants: US official

Act now or face action in 90 days: FATF

At least 23 killed in multiple suicide bombings, attacks in Afghanistan

Pakistan: The royal playground for the Arabs

Can talks in Oman end the war in Yemen?

‘Don’t kill terrorists in Pakistan; get them into Afghanistan’

Saudi Arabia now opens doors of military jobs to women

Amnesty International demands Saudi Arabia to halt execution of 14 Shia activists

Israel suffers major setback in Syria

Another threat of surgical operations: Is India challenging China in the backdrop?

A weak denial: Is Pakistan hiding facts behind sending troops to Saudia?

Saudi regime faces certain defeat in Yemen

TAPI ceremony brings Pakistan and India closer despite LoC violations

Saudi enslavement of Pakistan

White Helmets Ready for False-Flag Chemical Attack in Syria

Did Nawaz seek Modi's help to rescue him?

Saudi Arabia using Israeli language against Iran, Senator Aitzaz says

Peshawar Zalmi take on Multan Sultans in PSL 2018 opening fixture

Democracy was harmed for saving a person: Imran Khan

Nawaz Sharif seeks confrontation in judiciary, Parliament: Bilawal

ECP dismisses PML-N plea, declares its Senate candidates Independent

48 million Americans suffer from hunger

South Africa to cut diplomatic ties with Israel

Is Shahbaz Sharif stabbing Nawaz in the back?

Ghouta residents ‘wait for death’ amid holocaust

Pakistan adopts latest IAEA’s protocols on nuclear trade

Pakistan Deploys 1,000 Troops to Saudi Arabia amid Yemen War: Reasons, Consequences

Religious scholars to assist IHC in election act case

Nawaz Sharif: A Victim of his own Dirty schemes and Avarice

Supreme Court bars disqualified Nawaz Sharif from heading PML-N

Nawaz Sharif disqualified from party leadership

Iran and Qatar launch joint chamber of commerce

Hindu temple opens in Abu Dhabi .. Why the UAE seeks to appease Hindus?

Sharif family is a master of lies, deceit and hypocrisy, says Bilawal Bhutto

Syria blames West support for terrorists in a letter to UN

US motion to put Pakistan on terror financing watchlist differed

Senator fears Pakistani troops could get pulled into Yemen conflict

Russia will continue to boost Pakistan’s counterterrorism capacity, says FM Lavrov

Why US not trustworthy ally for Turkey

We can’t fight war of others on our soil, says Khawaja Asif

Constitution more supreme to parliament, remarks CJP

China woos Baloch militants to secure CPEC projects

PSL 3 trophy unveiling ceremony held in Dubai

Pakistani troops in the kingdom: A sudden and unexplained missive

Imran Khan suggests direct Senate elections to avoid horse-trading

Does parliament need judges’ say to legislate, asks PM

Pakistan, Azerbaijan enjoy cordial relations: Afzal

Why does Maryam relate all thief references with Nawaz, wonders Aitzaz Ahsan

Interior ministry refuses to put Sharif family’s names on ECL

PSL 2018: All you need to know about leagues, players

Photo of four women playing board game at Khana-e-Kaaba goes viral

Details of troops' deployment in Saudi Arabia can't be revealed: Senate told

Australia, US, India and Japan in talks to counter China’s spreading influence

Khawaja Asif leaves for Russia on 4-day visit

The tourist, found her way in Mashhad

French Noha at Imam Khoi Culture Center on Shahadat of Lady Fatima (S.A)

Pakistan looks to China, Saudi Arabia for succour

Iraqi court sentences Turkish woman to death for joining Islamic State

Impending crisis stopped PM from banning JuD, FIF

Yemen war: Trial time for Saudi Arabia?

US Muslims raise funds to assist Florida terrorist attack victims, Families

People to take revenge of my disqualification in 2018 polls: Nawaz

Imran’s third wedding news confirmed, Pictures released

Sharifs assets worth Rs58m 18 years back, court told

Who will keep Asma’s flame burning?

Sunnis are assured of Imam Mahdi’s reappearance: Sunni cleric

Bahraini Regime Committed Some 1,000 Human Rights Abuses in 1 Month: Report

Iran plane crash: All 66 people on board dead, says airline

Martyrdom of Hazrat Fatima (S.A)

The Story of Hazrat Fatima (sa), daughter of the Holy Prophet (pbuh)

US meddles in foreign nations elections for 'democracy': Ex CIA director

Zardari retracts statement calling Rao Anwar ‘brave kid’

PM sanctioned troop deployment to Saudi Arabia for ‘advisory purpose’

Shoaib Akhtar appointed PCB brand ambassador

‘Bajwa Doctrine’ working well against American blackmail

No militant camps exist on Pakistani soil: COAS

DRINKING HOT TEA CAN INCREASE RISK OF ESOPHAGEAL CANCER

Cannot wait to lift PSL trophy in Karachi: Sammy

Are Young People Abandoning Facebook or Not?

What’s behind Iranian President’s India visit?

Abbasi decides to abolish Gilgit-Baltistan Council

Why Asif Zardari defended Rao Anwar?

Zainab’s murderer sentenced to death by hanging on four counts

The View of Islam on the People and the Government

Senate summons defence minister over sending troops to Saudi Arabia

Abbasi gives go-ahead to PIA, PSM privatisation

US security services express fear of Pakistan’s nuclear program

Myanmar ready to take back Rohingya refugees

Why Shia-Sunni Unity Is Necessary & Important? Ayatollah Khamenei's Opinion

Farooq Sattar backs down; withdraws from selection of Senate candidates

PML-N instigated me to speak against army, offered Senate ticket in return: Ayesha Gulalai

Kuwaiti Emir hails Iran’s role in war on ISIS terror group

Supreme Court issues contempt notice to Rao Anwar

US, UK joint efforts to put Pakistan on terror watchlist

Florida school terrorist supports Trump, white supremacy, hates Muslims

Hasan Ali doubtful for initial PSL matches, Umaid Asif joins as cover

PRESS TV | Takfiri groups, a creation of West to divide Muslims: Iran president

Supporting terrorists, main objective of US-led coalition: Syria

2017-07-06 14:34:33

A Shiite perspective on political systems in Iraq – By Ayatollah Sayyid Jafar al-Hakim

SHAFAQNA – The relationship with heritage is a significant trait in religious thought, one which also interacts with it on the basis of that it is absolute and unerring (always rights and accurate). It is the relationship to one’s tradition and heritage – in this case Shia Islam, that allows for the formulation of its school of thought, and the categories that fall within it.

The  Shi’ite thought, or tradition has been enriched over two centuries under the care and teachings of the Imams, in addition to the Quran and the prophetic traditions. This has differentiated  Shia Islam from other schools of thoughts within Islam.

The practice  of unerring (action of an Infallible) comes in the context of  the infallible heritage, thereafter translated and passed down through jurisprudence to formulate the human behaviour. (The biography of rationality and the subscription).

When we observe the political practice of the unerring, we see that concepts may appear somewhat  antithetical:

For example while Shia thought  accepts the notion of power and accepts that power may be desired and thus pursues, it also refuses it and denounces its pursuants.

Shia thought accepts peaceful coexistence, while another promoted  the Jihad and revolt against the political rule.

It together  accepts political participation, and refuses it.

It accepts political compliance to a governor, and also defends the notion of political resistance  through struggle.

It at the same time define the political and the religious as distinct entities and also defines the religious and the political as extension of one another.

These antithetical pictures are rooted on the traditions that were passed down by the Imams in answer to their own specific socio-political circumstances. For example: Imam Ali’s isolation from power for over 20 years and the three wars he had to fight, Imam Hassan truce,  the revolution of Imam Hussein,  the monastic life of Imam Sajjad,  the scientific work of Al-Saddeghain,  the  struggle of Imam Kadim,  Imam Reza’s persecution …

Politics is not an inherent component of the Twelver school of thought in that no particular form of governance is a prerequisite to the formulation of the religious thought – in contrast to Sunni and Zaidi Islam.

The Twelver school of thought provides a wide margin of movement relative to one’s objectivity and opportunities.

It is possible to say that the political practice in Shiite thought allows for fluidity and movement, while provisioning for Taqiyah should the need arise. Unlike others schools of thought Twelver Islam allows for its followers to exercise reason and political discretion, thus training its followers to adapt, and practice restraint when needed.

Twelver Islam So its followers became open minded on all of the political outputs by positivity without the difficulty on the kind of governor and his sect and his political affiliation and his form of government.

The Shiite though has in fact opened up its followers to many potential scenarios, rationale and narratives, raising its followers on a state of contradiction and readiness to change, adapt and transform, according to needs, providing that certain constants remained:

  1. Identity
  2. Independence and lordship
  3. Social justice and proper opportunities

Authority and politics

In the era of the Great Ghibah [tale-bearing, gossip and backbiting) the need to return to the source of the law and knowledge was crystallised and thus the concept of reference within the Shia community reinforced through Ijtihad.

It is important to note that the Shiite thought neither legitimises authority, nor does it exercise the rule in its literal sense, but instead it moves according to needs and circumstances.

It deals with the authorities in the logic of mutual interests, and rejected the pretexts of government, power and state.

Just like the Imams only ever acted in the interests of the people, even to the detriment of their own person, the Shiite authority has worked to navigate those waters to safeguard Islam and the people.

The Shiite thought for example will support a monarchical system instead of rising a resistance as long as the people enjoy a degree of freedom, and justice be practiced.

However, it rose an opposition when it found that governments  practiced political sectarianism and the method of appointment that confiscated the will of the people and did not meet their interests.

There have been many instances where such “independence” has manifested.

  • The Shirazi refused the Tobacco Regie by issing the famous Tobacco Fatwa.

On March 20, 1890, Nasir al-Din Shah granted a concession to Major G. F. Talbot for a full monopoly over the production, sale, and export of tobacco for fifty years. In exchange, Talbot paid the shah an annual sum of £15,000 in addition to a quarter of the yearly profits after the payment of all expenses and a dividend of 5 percent on the capital. In December 1891 a fatwa was issued by the most important religious authority in Iran, marja’-i taqlid Mirza Hasan Shirazi, declaring the use of tobacco to be tantamount to war against the Hidden Imam, Muhammad al-Mahdi. The reference to the Hidden Imam, a critical person in Shia Islam, meant that Shirazi was using the strongest possible language to oppose the Régie. Initially there was skepticism over the legitimacy of the fatwa; however, Shirazi would later confirm the declaration.

Iranians in the capital of Tehran refused to smoke tobacco and this collective response spread to neighboring provinces. In a show of solidarity, Iranian merchants responded by shutting down the main bazaars throughout the country. As the tobacco boycott grew larger, Nasir al-Din Shah and Prime Minister Amin al-Sultan found themselves powerless to stop the popular movement fearing Russian intervention in case a civil war materialized.

Prior to the fatwa, tobacco consumption had been so prevalent in Iran that it was smoked everywhere, including inside mosques.

By January 1892, when the Shah saw that the British government “was waffling in its support for the Imperial Tobacco Company,” he canceled the concession.By January 26 Shirazi issued another fatwa repealing the first and permitting tobacco use, “and Iranians began smoking again.” The fatwa has been called a “stunning” demonstration of the power of the marja’-i taqlid, and the protest itself has been cited as one of the issues that led to the Constitutional Revolution a few years later.

  • The Hakim stood up to Marxism on account it denied the people the right to choose, and infringe on their civil liberties.
  • The Hakim rejected the killing of Kurds and their persecution on account they were too part of Iraq.
  • The Hakim and Khoei both refused to support the takeover of Kuwait during Ghasem and Saddam’s governance.
  • Al-Khoei  in Najaf refused to enter the  war with Iran.
  • Al- Sadr stood up to the Baath party when it infringed on people’s freedom of expression.

Such here above references demonstrate the fluidity of Shiite thought, and how it can adapt to many various forms of government provisioning that the people do not face persecution.

There have been many instances when the Shiite relgious authority has weighed carefully before complying or resisting particular forms of governance or governmental decisions on the premise that balance ought to be preserved and the interests of the people preserved.

The position so far has been one of balance where the Shiite thought has agreed to comply with various systems of governance on the provision that people and communities are offered and guaranteed certain inalienable freedoms, and abuses limited.

It is to guarantee political and social continuity that the Shiite authority has acted a quiet guardian, instead of dictating agendas, provisioning again that certain lines are not crossed.

The Shiite thought values content over manner, meaning that the principles of Shia Islam take precedent over the manner of which society may be governed.

It is true that the Shiite thought produced the concept of Wilayat al-Faqih (Governance of the Jurist as expressed by Ayatollah Khomeini) but the emergence of such system does not dismiss the validity of other positions.

The creation of a religious government/establishment led to disagreements in between

Jabal Amel scholars and Iran scholars in that both had different ideas as how to address the Safavi power in Iran.

Such struggle one may add exacerbated tensions within the region, which tensions were exploited by political actors.

Modern Day Iraq

Iraq’s Shiite authority did not part from its positions when faced with a new political landscape – it remained dedicated to the principles of the Shiite thought and carefully refrained from influencing the political not to interfere with the affairs of the state.

It acted positively and encouraged the community at large not to blur the line in between the religious and the political – a trend that has dominated world politics of late.

The goal was to promote self-determination and achieve balance.

Such position is a testament to the need to exercise distance in between state actors and the religious establishment to prevent corruption.

The message

There are two important points here that warrant to be stressed:

Number one, no party however entitled should ever rejoice before the demise of others, not even one enemy as it would be itself an act of great injustice. For Iraq to move away from the struggles it faced: from a brutal dictatorship, military occupation to sectarianism, the modern political structure of the country would have to reflect the will of the people. Everyone should share in the stability of Iraq.

Number two, I personally believe that the modern political philosophy which produced today’s modern political system – emptied  from ideology, has the power to match with the political Shiite thought which has been forwarded from Najaf to create a powerful political system that will allow for a new political alignment. Such opportunity must not be wasted, and I, for one, hope that all concerned parties will reflect upon such a historical juncture.

By Ayatollah Sayyid Jafar al-Hakim, senior cleric at Najaf (Iraq) seminary, for Shafaqna

Najaf seminary is the oldest and one of the most prominent centres of education, and thoughts for Shia Islam. 

Edited by Catherine Shakdam, Director Shafaqna Institute of Middle Eastern Studies

Categories:   Islamic News ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)