Why ICJ rushed to suspend execution of Indian spy?
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Shafaqna Exclusive: What is inside the classified Volume 10 of the JIT report?

Hindu nationalism risks pushing India into war with China

Trump ends CIA arms support for anti-Assad Syria rebels: Who believes?

How Raheel Sharif’s appointment will push Pakistan into another war?

Shutting Iranian cultural mission: Did Saudia threatened Kuwait by Qatar like consequences?

Houthi forces kill 3 soldiers inside Saudi Arabia

US airstrikes in Iraq and Syria kills 12 civilians per day

Plan of the United Arab Emirates to divide Yemen

JIT law firm is ‘one man show’

Cost benefit analysis: Why India cannot wage a war with China?

Stranded at border: Why Pakistan always neglected Shia pilgrims?

Hanging fate: What is better choice for PM, NAB or Court’s verdict?

Ayatollah Sistani: silent force behind ISIS defeat

NA-260 polls: How terrorists became blatant stakeholders in the constituency?

Mirzakhani, Iranian mathematician, was terrorized biologically in US; Russian intelligence services reveal

US speeds up military aid to PKK/PYD

US military, intelligence bodies harbor terrorists in region: Iranian lawmakers

Russia concerned of ISIS members being transported by unidentified helicopters to Afghanistan

ISIS, Al-Nusra, Al-Qaeda Get Their Money and Ideology From America’s Allies

SHAFAQNA | 8 British Muslims kick off Hajj journey on bikes

Spanish football federation chief arrested in fraud probe

SUCH TV | Russian airstrike obliterates Daesh ammo truck in southern Raqqa

China ‘Ready’ for Long-Term War With India

Intelligence Reports Suggest IS Leader Al-Baghdadi is Still Alive

Hazara's again: Four Hazaras shot dead near Mastung as gunmen open fire on vehicle

Confession of Saudia Iqama: Is Nawaz Sharif has been screwed?

Leaked documents reveal Saudia and Emirati crown princes support for Al-Qaeda and ISIS in Yemen

An inside informer to JIT: Who betrayed Sharif family?

Arrival of Qatar Foreign Minister: Is there give and take on Panama case?

Why West created ISIS?

Ruthless Saudi crackdown continues in Shiite regions with US green light

MEHR NEWS | Iran may opt to drop N-deal in face of major violation by US

ALMANAR | Saudi Arabia’s Rule: Grandson’s Era, Hatred Era

IQNA | Egyptian Qari Says Mostly Inspired by Minshawi

PRESS TV | US adding new sanctions against Iran over missile program

LUBP | Mr Sharif please don’t resign

Party rifts: Why is Ch Nisar angry over PM?

Pakistan’s journey to terrorism: From Madrassahs to high grade universities

Using the analogy of Gullen for Imran Khan: Is PML-N portraying PM as Erdogan?

End of Panamagate: All stage set to disqualify PM

Israel’s diplomatic expansion in the face of Arab retraction

Iran’s Zarif hopes Yemen war does not lead to Iran, Saudi conflict

Iran warns US of 'big risk' if it blacklists IRGC

At daggers drawn: Chinese cross border rocket attack kills 158 Indian soldiers

Takfiris fight each other as Assad ouster fades away

Trump Puts US Centcome in Al-Udeid on Auction to Blackmail S. Arabia, UAE

Saudi Arabia’s march towards civil war

What is the the Int'l Plot against Syria Using Refugee Issue?

Prof. Stephen Hawking Says Alien Life is Real, Warns Humans Not to Make Contact

A wind of change: Pakistan towards a corruption free state

Where the law prevails: Iranian president’s brother arrested on financial crime charges

US divorce to Pakistan: Would Russia take the revenge?

JIT Report: Top 10 legal minds on what next

Explosion hits Peshawar's Hayatabad, 2 FC men martyred several injured

Washington Post: US intelligence confirms UAE planned Qatar fake news hack

Saudi Arabia recognized death of 155 of its soldiers and commanders in Yemen

Ex-Saudi Crown Prince's Absence in Funeral Prayer for Uncle Proves Rumors about House Arrest

A message by Iran : Our forces can combat US troops 

Saudi breeds ‘fodder for terrorism’, says former British ambassador

Qatari camels die of thirst after farmers kicked out by Saudi Arabia as diplomatic rift deepens

Should Pakistan allow Jhadav’s mother to Pakistan?

CIA Agent Confesses On Deathbed: ‘We Blew Up WTC7 On 9/11’

Dump the Trump: Anti-Trump protests held across US demanding impeachement

Trying to protect Saudi Arabia,UK refuses to publish report on ‘funding of extremism’

Is Ch.Nisar happy over PM’s indictment?

A secrete story of success: How Pakistan helped Iraq in defeating ISIS?

ABNA | Three Shia martyred in attack by Saudi forces in Qatif / PHOTOS

TASNIM | Saudi Hypocrisy Targeting Qatar Nothing but Insanity: US Analyst

SHABESTAN | Ten days of blessings is a golden chance to explain Islamic joy based on Rizvi culture

IQNA | US Supreme Court Asked to Overturn Muslim Ban Ruling

PRESS TV | Iran blasts Israel’s closure of al-Aqsa Mosque

Al-Qaeda-Linked Filmmaker's Work on CNN Syria Documentary Unmentioned by Network

Tillerson's failed attempt: Did Saudia demand a regime change in Qatar?

Cholera outbreak in Yemen poses risk to Hajj pilgrims: WHO

A crooked PM: Another corruption scandal embroils Netanyahu

Trump’s son-in-law tried to get $500mn loan from Qatar

Hard days ahead: Can Pakistan survive without US aid?

Accountability for all : Are the Judges and General next after politicians?

Trump declares ‘Zionist Holy war’ on Iran

A tainted PM: Hanging sword of disqualification on Sharif’s family

Seizure of assets: Is Countdown beginning for Imran Khan?

Why Iran’s supreme leader clubbed Kashmir with Yemen, and not with Palestine

IQNA | Riyadh Regime Seeking to Silence Shia Dissent with Execution

MEHR NEWS | Saudis fail to issue anti-Iran statement at OIC

SUCH TV | Reko Diq case: Pakistan rejects $11.5b damages claim

Secrete eyes: 25,000 Chinese Spies Embedded in U.S.

Why the International community takes no responsibility toward Yemen?!!

British Jews urge London Mayor to get Hizbullah banned

Shrugging off resignation: Is Zardari’s show once again on to save Nawaz Sharif?

PM trapped: What is that evidence that alone can send Nawaz Sharif packing?

Shafaqna Special: Indo-Israel secrete venture to fund for separate Balochistan?

Pentagon Can Keep Secret Chemical Weapons Tests on US Troops

Bin Salman’s difficult journey to Saudi throne

Erdogan will be arrested in Sweden over genocide and crimes against humanity

150 Saudi intelligence officers joined Daesh in Mosul battle: Report

Amnesty: Saudi Arabia silence Shia dissent with execution

Did Saudia use biological weapons that unleashed cholera in Yemen?

Saudia's economic death: 670,000 expats to leave Saudi Arabia in 3 years

US Forces Could Have Killed Kim Jong-un on July 4 But Didn’t Take the Shot

UK Profiting From Yemeni Civilians Suffering: HRW

2017-05-18 16:07:25

Why ICJ rushed to suspend execution of Indian spy?

b088b8bbf5148d7e17f77ef7d8cd37ca2d306205Give the devil due credit. The case in point is of Pakistan’s arch rival India which made better diplomatic manoeuvres and built up a perception internationally that Islamabad may soon execute its convicted senior Naval official Kulbushan Jadhav on spying charges. This presumably misled International Court of Justice (ICJ) to rush to suspend his execution.

Jadhav was handed down a death sentence by Pakistan’s Field General Court Martial few weeks ago and his execution was nowhere in sight in months to come given the lengthy legal process in Pakistan which Indian government has been pursuing.
This was the precise reason that the ICJ noted in its short order that there is a risk that an execution of Indian spy could occur at any moment and therefore, “In those circumstances, the court is satisfied that there is urgency in the present case”.

Pakistan had its own cogent reasons to argue that ICJ lacks the jurisdiction to arbitrate on the subject. Therefore, Islamabad on March 29 this year withdrew ICJ jurisdiction chiefly on following specific grounds.

1)- Disputes relating to or connected with any aspect of hostilities, armed conflicts, individual or collective self-defense or the discharge of any functions pursuant to any decision or recommendation of international bodies, the deployment of armed forces abroad, as well as action relating and ancillary thereto in which Pakistan is, has been or may in future be involved;

2)- Disputes with regard to which any other party to a dispute has accepted the compulsory jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice exclusively for or in relation to the purposes of such dispute; or where the acceptance of the Court’s compulsory jurisdiction on behalf of a party to the dispute as deposited or ratified less than 12 months prior to the filing of the application bringing the dispute before the Court.

There are, however, serious questions as to why Pakistan delayed its decision to withdraw the jurisdiction of ICJ. Policy markers in Islamabad failed to foresee the direction to which this critically important case could have gone in international legal forums.
That is not the whole truth. Here is more. The fact that both countries are signatories to Vienna Convention, has played out well for India to flex its legal muscle at ICJ. Legally speaking at the heart of interpretation is Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention, which provides that the Court has jurisdiction over “disputes arising out of the interpretation or application of the [Vienna] Convention”. Therefore, ICJ invoked the jurisdiction of article-1 of Vienna Convention to set aside legal pleas of Pakistan about its lack of jurisdiction to hear Jadhav’s case. Islamabad’s citation about a 2008’s bilateral agreement between two countries on excluding spies from the application of law under Vienna Convention to provide councillor access was also ignored on the basis of article-1.

Had Islamabad also withdrawn ICJ’s jurisdiction of “Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention”, Pakistan would not have suffered legal setbacks to its strong case on how a serving Indian Naval official was engaged in systematic network of espionage through which he on the behalf of his government sponsored terrorism particularly in southwest of the country.

ICJ should have had a Pakistani ad-hoc judge on its panel before it could have ordered to stay the execution of Indian spy. However, in the rush to deliver a favourable verdict to India, ICJ made this known legal practice yet another causality in the administration of justice.

Nonetheless, the legal battle is far from over. Pakistan has a strong case to plead at the end of the day when each and every legal aspect of the case would be deliberated upon in regular hearings.

It is not a just confessional statement of Jadhav which supports Pakistan’s case but his dual passports to say the least. Interestingly he was Hindu in India and Muslim in Iranian border region with Pakistan. And as per flimsy claims by New Delhi, he was only “engaged in a legitimate business of operating ferries from the Iranian port town of Bandar Abbas”.

Such arguments would make more sense in New Delhi than at ICJ during the course of legal arguments in weeks to come.

 
Categories:  
From other agencies (RSS Reader)

2 dead in Greece earthquake 

- worldbulletin.net

Press agenda on July 21

- worldbulletin.net

PET Exports to EU

- brecorder