Why ICJ rushed to suspend execution of Indian spy?

US warns Pakistan to cross border if needed

 Pakistan budget: Why is health neglected again?

Saudi Arabia after splitting Muslim people: Yemen’s Houthi

ABNA | Bahraini forces storm into residence of Sheikh Isa Qassim - Pics

Peace and Violence in Islam

The Holy Month of Ramadan: The Month of Glory, Forbearance, Patience and Brotherhood

Who is Sheikh Isa Qassim and how dangerous is he for Bahrain monarchy?

Manchester attack: Why Theresamay should step down?

Slashed military aid: Is US committing blunder to abandon Pakistan?

Mutual detriment: Why Pakistan-Iran partnership is need of the hour?

US nuclear fuel fire may lead to much larger disaster than Fukushima: Study

It’s not America; Saudi Arabia has the greatest army and highest military expenditure in the world

ALALAM | Qatar plays down fears of rift with Arab states over "fake" criticism by emir

PRESS TV | Trump clashes with world leaders at G7 meeting

SHIAPOST | Pakistan not to jeopardize ties with Iran: Speaker NA Ayaz Sadiq

SHIITENEWS | PAKISTAN ARMY CHIEF LIKELY TO VISIT TEHRAN

US arms deals will fail to make Saudi secure: Iran FM

Egypt blocks 21 websites, including Al Jazeera: state news agency

WAHDAT NEWS | On the basis of Riyals, Safiani Lashkar is being prepared to fight against Imam Mehdi a.s.. Allama Ameen Shahidi

SHABESTAN NEWS | Reality of Islam and conspiracies of enemy must be exposed

SUCH NEWS | FINANCE MINISTER ISHAQ DAR UNVEILS RS4.778 TRILLION BUDGET 2017-18

Budget 2017: Important highlights

MEHR NEWS | Iran’s military delegation arrives in Pakistan

Finance minister unveils budget of Rs4.778 trillion

Would a surgical strike trigger Indo-Pak nuclear war?

Saudi and UAE target Qatar's media and website over Iran's support

Pakistan not to jeopardize ties with Iran: Ayaz Sadiq

JIT probe: Is PML-N trying to throw spanners in the work?

A movement of shame: How Saudia betrayed Pakistan?

Wahhabism to ISIS:How Saudi Arabia exported the main source of global terrorism

Iran has built third underground missile factory: Senior IRGC commander

IRNA | Pope Francis puts spotlight on King Salman disregard for religious values

IQNA | Quran Competition for Students Held in Sweden

ISLAM TIMES | Qatari King’s Pro-Iranian Statement False or Authentic?

ABNA | Presidency: Sheikh Zakzaky is not in prison, he's with his wife and children

SHABESTAN NEWS | We demand immediate release of Sheikh Isa Qasim

MEHR NEWS | Iran, Russia, Turkey can help peace, stability in region

All you must know about Salman Abedi, the Manchester suicide bomber

Suppressing free speech: Is Nawaz Govt trying to appease military?

Threat of another war: Pakistan makes all forward airbases operational

PAKISTANI AMONG THREE IN RUN FOR TOP WHO OFFICE

SUCH NEWS | THOUSANDS PROTEST TRUMP’S VISIT TO BELGIUM

Debunking myths on CPEC

Sharifs start playing cat and mouse game with JIT

Doctors seek meaningful increase in health budgets

Trump’s illusion: Did US forget 9/11 episode?

Rouhani’s victory: A blow for Saudia and US

Would India attack Pakistan if Yadav hanged?

No country should affect Tehran-Islamabad ties: Iranian official

Punjab Law Minister says Iran helped Pakistan in every hour of need

ISLAMQUEST | Is it obligatory to make wudu after ghusl in order to offer prayers?

LUBP | Syria’s Assad just explained how America really works

ALMANAR NEWS | President Aoun: Lebanon Not Committed to Final Statement of Riyadh Summit

ALMASDAR NEWS | Palestine goes on world’s largest hunger strike

ALWAQT | What Did Trump Seek in His West Asia Trip?

ABNA | Pakistani Op Leader: Isolating Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas not in Muslim world’s interest

IRNA | Saudis show angry response to pro-Iran remarks by Qatari emir

SHEBESTAN NEWS AGENCY | UNICEF calls for end of violence in Myanmar

IQNA | Iranian Qari Comes 2nd in Turkey Int’l Quran Contest

Islam Times | Pakistan to Quit Saudi Coalition if Iran Targeted: Defense Minister

Mehr New | Syrian army re-establishes control over al-Jarah Airport in Aleppo

After $2billion deal; Indian Navy again signs $630 million deal with Israel

Over 12,000 individuals trained to control cyber crimes : FIA

Yet another embarrassing moment for Donald Trump

Americans ask: Why is Saudi monarchy our friend, but not democratic Iran?

Saudi Arabia agrees to form a coalition government in Yemen

Alarming threats: Why Pakistan is downplaying Daesh threat in Karachi?

Yadav’s case: Did Nawaz Sharif commit treason?

The conference of shame and disgrace

Muslim countries participation in Riyadh’s meeting is contrary to Islamic values

Another gamble: Abbas to propose large-scale land swap with Israel

Denouncing Terror – Islam promotes the good and forbids the bad EDITORIAL

Shafaqna Interviews Brother Ali-Reza Goudarzi on the Architecture of the Holy Shrines

Bahraini forces attack a number of anti regime protesters

Murderers of Muslim Ummah: $380 billion to spill the blood of Muslims

A dangerous move: US’s Iranophobia for Saudi dollars

At least 22 killed, over 59 injured in suicide attack at Manchester concert

PM Nawaz condemns Manchester blast, calls for concerted efforts against terrorism

Rouhani’s re-election: The challenges ahead

War on extremism: The state, Maulana Abdul Aziz and Masood Azhar

A day dream: Can Trump Isolate Iran?

Indian army awards officer who tied Kashmiri man to jeep as human shield

Widow of 9/11 victim to Trump: Saudis should be held accountable for ‘role in murdering 3,000’

Why Muslims need to take part in their own affairs?

Conference on Takfirism to be held in Denmark

Ayatollah Bashir al-Najafi: “Clerics responsible to inform societies”

Imran slams Nawaz for being silent spectator at Saudi summit

The end of Trump

Moving Security Council after ICJ: Do India enjoy an upper hand in Yadav’s case?

Pakistanis ashamed at how PM Nawaz was treated in Saudi Arabia: Imran Khan

US Senator censures $110Bn arms sale to Saudis, citing atrocities in Yemen

US airstrike on Syrian Army proves Washington’s fake claims about war on terrorism

Syrian conflict:  Saudia diplomacy to foil peace talks

Rising threat: ‘Extremist outfits radicalising educated women in Karachi’

MWM Conference demands Pakistan’s withdraw from Saudi Military Alliance

Reasons why Arab NATO is doomed to failure

Iranian FM responds to Trump's anti-Tehran remarks

Robert Fisk from Independent: “Donald Trump’s speech to the Muslim world was filled with hypocrisy and condescension”

Trump’s Pro Saudi stance is a tragic continuation of US foreign policy of being aligned with the creators of Al Qaeda

I did not fast in my early years of adulthood, is it Wajib for me to compensate for those days and pay Kaffarah?

2017-05-18 16:07:25

Why ICJ rushed to suspend execution of Indian spy?

b088b8bbf5148d7e17f77ef7d8cd37ca2d306205Give the devil due credit. The case in point is of Pakistan’s arch rival India which made better diplomatic manoeuvres and built up a perception internationally that Islamabad may soon execute its convicted senior Naval official Kulbushan Jadhav on spying charges. This presumably misled International Court of Justice (ICJ) to rush to suspend his execution.

Jadhav was handed down a death sentence by Pakistan’s Field General Court Martial few weeks ago and his execution was nowhere in sight in months to come given the lengthy legal process in Pakistan which Indian government has been pursuing.
This was the precise reason that the ICJ noted in its short order that there is a risk that an execution of Indian spy could occur at any moment and therefore, “In those circumstances, the court is satisfied that there is urgency in the present case”.

Pakistan had its own cogent reasons to argue that ICJ lacks the jurisdiction to arbitrate on the subject. Therefore, Islamabad on March 29 this year withdrew ICJ jurisdiction chiefly on following specific grounds.

1)- Disputes relating to or connected with any aspect of hostilities, armed conflicts, individual or collective self-defense or the discharge of any functions pursuant to any decision or recommendation of international bodies, the deployment of armed forces abroad, as well as action relating and ancillary thereto in which Pakistan is, has been or may in future be involved;

2)- Disputes with regard to which any other party to a dispute has accepted the compulsory jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice exclusively for or in relation to the purposes of such dispute; or where the acceptance of the Court’s compulsory jurisdiction on behalf of a party to the dispute as deposited or ratified less than 12 months prior to the filing of the application bringing the dispute before the Court.

There are, however, serious questions as to why Pakistan delayed its decision to withdraw the jurisdiction of ICJ. Policy markers in Islamabad failed to foresee the direction to which this critically important case could have gone in international legal forums.
That is not the whole truth. Here is more. The fact that both countries are signatories to Vienna Convention, has played out well for India to flex its legal muscle at ICJ. Legally speaking at the heart of interpretation is Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention, which provides that the Court has jurisdiction over “disputes arising out of the interpretation or application of the [Vienna] Convention”. Therefore, ICJ invoked the jurisdiction of article-1 of Vienna Convention to set aside legal pleas of Pakistan about its lack of jurisdiction to hear Jadhav’s case. Islamabad’s citation about a 2008’s bilateral agreement between two countries on excluding spies from the application of law under Vienna Convention to provide councillor access was also ignored on the basis of article-1.

Had Islamabad also withdrawn ICJ’s jurisdiction of “Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention”, Pakistan would not have suffered legal setbacks to its strong case on how a serving Indian Naval official was engaged in systematic network of espionage through which he on the behalf of his government sponsored terrorism particularly in southwest of the country.

ICJ should have had a Pakistani ad-hoc judge on its panel before it could have ordered to stay the execution of Indian spy. However, in the rush to deliver a favourable verdict to India, ICJ made this known legal practice yet another causality in the administration of justice.

Nonetheless, the legal battle is far from over. Pakistan has a strong case to plead at the end of the day when each and every legal aspect of the case would be deliberated upon in regular hearings.

It is not a just confessional statement of Jadhav which supports Pakistan’s case but his dual passports to say the least. Interestingly he was Hindu in India and Muslim in Iranian border region with Pakistan. And as per flimsy claims by New Delhi, he was only “engaged in a legitimate business of operating ferries from the Iranian port town of Bandar Abbas”.

Such arguments would make more sense in New Delhi than at ICJ during the course of legal arguments in weeks to come.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories:  
From other agencies (RSS Reader)

Taakra 27 May 2017

- waqtnews