How Orientalism Pitted Hindus against Muslims in India?
Video     Photos     Pakistan     World     Islam     Health     Crime     Islamic News     Business     Society     India     Travel     Middle East     Sport     sci/tech      Contact      RSS
Search

Army chief assures nations elements behind Parachinar attack to be brought to book

SUCH TV | Imran Khan criticizes Prime Minister Sharif over not meeting Quetta, Parachinar mourners

AL ALAM | Trump Causes 'Major' Shift in Global View of US: Pew

PRESS TV | Fresh US-led strikes leave 30 dead in eastern Syrian village

MEHR NEWS | How bizarre Saudi Arabia is behaving!

US fighting Israel’s proxy war against Iran

Crown Prince of UAE asked Americans to bomb Al Jazeera headquarters Wikileaks reveals

US May Be Preparing for 'Preemptive Strike' on Syria Amid Chemical Weapons Claim

Meeting of two terrorists: Why is US silent on Indian terrorism inside Pakistan?

Why Saudi Arabia hates Al Jazeera so much

Chernobyl nuclear power plant hit by 'Petya' ransomware attack causing havoc across the globe

Kashmir’s Mirwaiz thanks Iran’s Ayotallah Khamenei for rallying behind Kashmir struggle

Berlin: Saudi demands from Qatar ‘very provocative’

Are There any Limits to U.S. Hypocrisy?

Donald Trump abandons traditional White House Ramadan celebration

Stunning Images That Capture The Beauty Of Eid In America

US-led coalition killed more Syrian civilians than Isis

Trump ends White House Ramadan dinners, breaking 20-yr "tradition"

Was the Panama JIT hijacked before its constitution?

The Inside game: Would Capt (R) Safdar become an approver in Panama case?

Is US relocating ISIS terrorists to Afghanistan, Central Asia?

White House Appears to Be Planning Attack on Assad

Bhawalpur tragedy: Who should be held accountable?

Turkey won’t allow establishment of a state in northern Syria: President Erdoğan

Pakistan marks grim Eid after heavy death toll in oil tanker inferno, Parachinar and Quetta blast

Operation ‘Radul Artedad : What is Ansar al Sharia and who is leading it?

Pot calling the kettle black: Why US cannot blame Pakistan for backing Haqqanis?

 Iran, China Increasing Military Exchanges

Failed militarily, Saudis seek controlling Yemen’s vital port through UN

PRESS TV | Saudi king relieves Nayef as crown prince

AMN | Is Europe pursuing an independent foreign policy direction?

Saudi Reshuffle Could Completely Shake Up Oil Markets

Pakistan to celebrate Eid ul Fitr on Monday

Radioactive Truth: How did US steal Afghanistan's Uranium in Helmand

Nearly 150 killed in fuel tanker fire in Pakistan

Shafaqna Interviews Brother Mubashir Sheriff from Zainab Rights

The Actual Meaning of Eid

Another Earth-Size World May Lurk in the Outer Solar System

Saudi prince reveals ‘US conditions’ for Mohamed Bin Salman to be king

Nightmare for Zionism: How Hezbollah’s future war with Israel can draw fighters even from Pakistan?

Another confession of Yadav: Has Pakistan failed to convince world about Indian terrorism?

Houthis attack targets inside Saudi Arabia

130 killed in oil tanker fire in Bahawalpur

Rise of a war monger: Why Pakistan would be more under pressure by new crown prince?

US bill to revoke Pakistan’s major ally status: Is it a blessing in disguise for Pakistan?

Egypt’s Sisi ratifies controversial islands deal with Saudis

'Islamic State K-P chief' among two killed in Peshawar raid, major attack on Eid averted

Downing the drone: What caused the trust deficit between Pakistan and Iran?

AMN : BREAKING: Israeli warplane bombs Syrian army in Quneitra

Islamic Center of England Awards Winners of Quran Contest

ABNA | Ayatollah Fezel Lankarani: Al Saud's crimes in Yemen like Israel's in Palestine

MEHR NEWS | Iran strongly slams imminent attack on Mecca Grand Mosque

SHIITENEWS | Allama Raja Nasir announces 3-day mourning on Parachinar tragedy

Remembering what the Supreme leaders of Iran said about Al-Quds day

US-Led Airstrikes Killed 472 Civilians in Syria in the Past Month

Turks flock to mosque to view clothes which belonged to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)

Hired gun: Is war with Iran now inevitable under new Saudi crown prince?

Demands list: Would Qatar cut ties with Iran?

Nawaz fools the nation again: Saudia denies Pakistan’s efforts in gulf crisis mediation?

Saudi security forces claim to foil Mecca terror plot

Saudi, allies demands not 'realistic': Qatar

Pakistan under attack: Multiple attacks before eid leave country mourning

SHABESTAN | Charity gives life to this world and hereafter

TAGHRIB NEWS | Iran, world countries mark Quds Day with rallies

ALWAGHT | Saudi-Led Arab Regimes Issue Qatar with 13 Demands to End Blockade

TASHIM NEWS | Iranian Speaker Brands Israel as Mother of Terrorism

US Under Pressure to Accept North Korea Nuclear Freeze Deal

Second blast in a day: Parachinar blast death toll mounts to 30

Mass killing of Palestinians: Rabbi Calls for Poisoning of Palestinian Water Supply

Drone episode: Pakistan warns Iran over spying

15 killed in blast on Quetta's Gulistan road

Islam vs West: Is it the time of clash of civilizations?

The disastrous rise of Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman

Agencies face off: Is IB and MI are face to on Panama JIT?

Backdoor politics: Did PPP strike a covert deal with Nawaz Sharif on Panama leaks?

Foreign-sponsored Syria opposition losing influence: Russia FM

Whistle-Blower: Saudi Arabia, UAE Plotting to Stage Coup in Qatar

Game of Thrones: What's Behind Saudi King Salman's Change of Heart

18 Israeli Fighter Jets Deployed in S. Arabia to Prevent Coup

Finally UN awakes: Israel relations with armed Syrian groups are a ‘concern’

PRESS TV | Daesh blows up Mosul’s iconic al-Nuri Mosque

IRFAN | A sinner can not claim…

ISLAMQUEST | What is the principle of no domination over Muslims?

MEHR NEWS | Iran missile attacks killed over 170 terrorists in Deir Ezzor

IQNA | Fighting Zionist Regime Is Fighting Arrogance, Hegemonic Order

IMAMREZA.NET | The Great Crisis of our Age

"Would you like a drink of water?" Please ask a Yemeni child

U-Turn on Assad: France’s Macron says Assad removal no longer necessary

Has Pakistan decided to soften its stance on Kulbhoshan Yadav?

Takfiri Daesh blows up Mosul mosque where it declared ‘caliphate’

New Saudi crown prince: Saudi King’s final stroke to push Middle East into fire

Can Pakistan stay neutral in Saudi-Qatar conflict?

The tacit deal: Why Raheel Sharif cannot be recalled from Saudia?

Hamid Karzai rejects Saudi Arabia’s demand

Tel Aviv satisfied over appointment of Salman as crown prince…newspaper Ha’ertz: “It is good news for Israel”

Countries that are at 'Risk Becoming the First Targets of Daesh' in the Balkans

Wrong in the bottom: Why is EU opposing hangings of terrorists in Pakistan?

Rising tension: Russia threatens to shoot down US planes

ALWAGHT | Palace Coup in Saudi Arabia as King Sacks Crown Prince Nayef, Appoints Son, Bin Salman

Afridi, Malik back in T20, ODI teams

2017-03-12 23:41:14

How Orientalism Pitted Hindus against Muslims in India?

400px-Anonymous_Venetian_orientalist_painting_The_Reception_of_the_Ambassadors_in_Damascus_1511_the_LouvreSHAFAQNA – The most outstanding feature of Islam is its history; if you study Islamic history, you would come to realize that Islam did not spread by force alone, it was the superior moral appeal of its peerless ethics that won the hearts and minds of medieval masses. For instance: Mongols conquered most of the eastern lands of the Islamic Empire during the thirteenth century, however, the Muslims of those lands did not convert to the religion of the conquerors: that is, the Mongolian Shamanism. Instead, the conquerors adopted the religion of the vanquished, i.e. Islam. Not only the Mongols, but several Turkish tribes also voluntarily converted to Islam. Such was the beauty of Islamic teachings and its sublime moral appeal in ancient times.

During the medieval times, when Europe was going through an age of intellectual and moral regression, Islamic culture thrived and flourished under the Abbasids, Ottomans and Mughals. Muslims ruled over India for more than six centuries; despite that, at the time of the independence of India and Pakistan in 1947, Hindus outnumbered Muslims three to one (there were only 100 million Muslims in the population of 400 million Indians in 1947). That’s how tolerant and inclusive Islamic culture was back then. By comparison, the Red Indians of America and the Aborigines of Australia were reduced to a tiny minority of those continents after the European invasions.

The Sultanate of Delhi and the Mughal Empire were regarded as benevolent rulers by ancient historians. But when India was conquered by the British Empire, their Orientalist historians deliberately propagated the myth of supposedly “savage and rapacious” rule of Muslims in India in order to sow the seeds of dissension between Muslims and Hindus. In the nineteenth century, the newly established British education system in India deliberately portrayed Muslim rulers of India as marauders, rapists and looters in order to malign them. By contrast, the British rule in India was portrayed in a positive light: that the British Empire built roads and railways and established schools, colleges and hospitals in India.

If we were to compare the British and Muslim rules in India, the Muslim rulers at least resided in India and shared their wealth and fortune with their subjects. The British rule, on the other hand, was a foreign rule; the affairs of the state were run by viceroys and governors on the behalf of the monarchs of England who resided thousands of miles away in London. A small number of European colonizers in India treated their subjects as untouchables; they traded raw materials for pennies and sent finished goods back to the Indian market with huge profits, thus enriching themselves and the British Empire.

Up until 1857, the Hindus and Muslims of India were united enough to rise up in arms together against the British colonizers under the nominal command of the last Mughal emperor, Bahadur Shah Zafar. But after that, the British education system introduced by Lord Macaulay in India entrenched communal divisions and made it virtually impossible for Hindus and Muslims to understand each other, even though both religious communities were the victims of exploitation of foreign rule.

Regarding the notion peddled by the Orientalist historians that Muslims or Islam were somehow foreign to India, we need to settle on the definition of nativity first. If an Indian settles in the US, for instance, how would you define such a first generation immigrant? Since he was brought up in India and subsequently migrated to a Western country, therefore such a first generation Indian-American would have more in common with Indians than Americans, as such. But how would you identify the children of an immigrant who have been brought up and educated in the West? The second generation Indian-Americans, for all practical purposes, would be more American than Indian in their outlooks.

Similarly, although I concede that the invading armies of Muslim rulers from Central Asia, Afghanistan and Iran were foreign to India; but once they settled in India, made Delhi their seat of governance, intermarried and gave birth to Indian children, then how come the descendants of such benevolent rulers be labeled as foreign invaders? Excluding a few odd adventurers, like Mahmud of Ghazni, who had his seat of government in Afghanistan but plundered the wealth of India by conducting raids on Somnath, the Muslim rulers of India, particularly the Sultanate of Delhi and the Mughal Empire, were as much native to India as the Hindu and Sikh rajas and maharajas.

Notwithstanding, the only true sociological definition of nation is ethno-linguistic group. The concept of modern nation state, particularly in multiethnic federations like India and Pakistan, is an artificial construct which is predicated on nothing substantive but on myths, fables and symbols. Rather than monolithic communities, the Hindus and Muslims of India were more parochial and tribal in character.

The astute Orientalist historians of British India debunked the myth of six centuries’ old Muslim rule in India by calling them “marauders” and substituted it with the fables of the pre-Christ Maurya Empire in order to forge and reify Hindu identity against Muslims. The primary concern of impoverished Indian masses was to earn bread and butter for their families. The metanarratives of Hindu and Muslim nationalism were taught by the British rulers, Hindu elites and Muslim ashrafiya to their subjects in order to distract and exploit them.

Here, let me clarify that I am not giving a free pass to the Muslim rulers of India. Their rule must have been as tyrannical as any other undemocratic, elitist rule throughout the history has been. I am only contending that the Muslim rulers were deliberately singled out and vilified in order to sow the seeds of dissension between the two communities.

After all, if the British rulers who resided in England and ruled over India can be hailed as saviors who built roads and railways and established schools, colleges and hospitals, not by academics but by common Indian citizens, then why can’t the Sultanate of Delhi and the Mughal Empire that ensured peace and stability in India and built architectural wonders in Delhi, Lahore and Agra be granted a similar level of deference?

By the British divide-and-rule policy in the Indian context, it is generally assumed by Indian historians that the British rulers used the Muslim minority against the Hindu majority by giving the former preferential treatment, separate electorates etc. but the fact is often overlooked that the British imperialists in equal measure used the Hindus against the Muslims by vilifying the latter’s culture, rule and religion.

Moreover, the partition of Bengal on religious lines in 1905 was another classic instance of the British divide-and-rule policy through demographic change. In this case, the British imperialists cleverly partitioned the Hindu-majority Bengal province into the Muslim-majority East Bengal and the Hindu-majority West Bengal. As a consequence, the Hindus felt aggrieved and launched a mass movement against the partition; the Raj obliged the Hindus by accepting their demand of reunifying Bengal in 1911 which created a sense of alienation and deprivation among Muslims.

This time around, however, despite unifying the province along linguistic lines, at the same time the British rulers split up Bihar and Orissa province to the west and Assam province to the east; thus, reducing the initial Hindu majority (pre-1905) that included Bihar, Orissa and Assam, in favor of Muslim majority (post-1911) in the reunified Bengal. Additionally, the British rulers also devised separate electorates for Muslims in 1909; thus, pitting one community against the other which had lived peacefully for centuries before the arrival of British in India.

Finally, rather than cultivating inclusive Indian nationalism that would glorify Hindu, Muslim and Sikh identities and histories in equal measure, the British rulers maliciously nurtured exclusionary Hindu and Muslim nationalism in order to divide the communities and prolong the British rule. As several contemporary Indian historians have contended that Muslim nationalism in India was a reaction to exclusionary Hindu nationalism.

The political leadership of India was the product of British education system that forged artificial identities and entrenched communal divisions, therefore it was not possible for them to rise above their communal prejudices and work for the betterment of all Indians as a nation. This self-serving, divide-and-rule policy by the British rulers and their Hindu, Muslim and Sikh collaborators eventually led to a carnage and mass exodus of people on the eve of independence the likes of which history has seldom witnessed.

Nauman Sadiq is an Islamabad-based attorney, columnist and geopolitical analyst focused on the politics of Af-Pak and MENA regions, neocolonialism and Petroimperialism.

The original source of this article is Global Research

 
Categories:   Other News ،
From other agencies (RSS Reader)

Bloody track record!

- mehrnews.com

US stock market opens higher

- worldbulletin.net